"We did it, Patrick! We made a technological breakthrough!"
A place for all those who loathe AI to discuss things, post articles, and ridicule the AI hype. Proud supporter of working people. And proud booer of SXSW 2024.
I'm not going to stop using em dashes. Find a different indicator!
It's one piece. You tell me I want to spot cars one thing they have is wheels, I'm not going to immediately assume every bike I see is a car. But taken with other signs it builds a pattern.
Honestly I've found the best way to spot LLM is just use it an absolute crap ton. You'll start to be able to spot it the way you can recognise the style of an author or director.
Same.
Weird analogies and similes
Well, guess I'm half AI or, to put it another way, I'm similar to a machine that's being frequently affected by cosmic rays when doing calculations
Although I wonder how long these signs would be that effective for, since they seem really model-specific.
Repeating the same content with different wording later in the text. For instance: saying the same statement you did earlier a little differently
It's like they read a Vonnegut book and said, "That right there is peak human!" And I'd agree!
Please don't give this any credit. Nonsense like this is already being used to filter web form submissions for things like job applications.
Source: I applied for a role at a medium-sized company a couple weeks ago and was auto-rejected because my cover letter appeared to be AI-generated. I clicked "back", removed an em-dash, and the form was accepted.
Yeah, having the same problem, but with social media. I've been using em dashes since the nineties, when I found out a pretty dash is just option-dash on my Mac. Switched almost to full time Linux now, still using em dashes. I tried using only minus signs for a time, but muscle memory is hard to beat.
TIL that following many decades of carefully observed writing best practices makes you an AI.
Welp, TIL that I’m a LLM. I frequently use at like 75% of those in my creative writing. I learned to use all of these by reading books.
The summary isnt hitting the nuance.
I see a lot of AI garbage.
You get emojis as list elements. You see a lot of dry writing, like you're reading a blog. You get vague nothings that sound good, but are meaningless.
That's the issue - so did AI. Real people use them less often because real people often don't read a lot of books. AI might not really understand the words it's spewing out, but it's at least good at formatting them as it's been shown.
Fuck — as an designer and typography nerd I just love them em-dashes.
It’s “em dash” and there shouldn’t be spaces around it. FYI.
I'm sure I've used some software that's auto corrected hyphens to em-dashes too, but I can't remember what.
Outlook does
As a writer myself, I find this rather depressing. I use parallel sentence structure, group things in threes, use unusual-but-accurate words, and come up with my own metaphors because those are good ways to make your point. I'm also inclined to restate and overclarify things to minimize the chance of being misunderstood. I hate the idea of my writing being mistaken for AI slop. At least I type my em-dashes as --, which LLMs don't do.
This is the issue. It's not that this is "LLM writing style". It is just formal writing. The thing is most people write like third graders, so these stick out with good reason, just not that 'it is AI'.
In general there aren't good ways to tell TBH. Literally giving it the command to 'not write like an AI' would make half of these disappear.
Having the AI edit a text for you would add some of these. Not because it is AI, but because that's proper writing.
You can take em—dash out of my cold dead hands
where do you think they learned it?
Maybe you're actually a llm? And you're slowly learning to disguise that you are by using --
I don't think it's necessarily just a checklist of things, but rather the way an LLM's output resembles these techniques that puts it into an uncanny valley of writing. As a writer, you use these techniques deliberately and thoughtfully. LLMs can't do that, so the output just feels off.
For me the most obvious tell is using 16 paragraphs to say something that could have been said with 16 words.
You just described the last two decades of cooking/recipe websites.
Dr. Ian Malcom: “SEO ruins succinct writing, AI trains on bloated SEO ‘optimized’ text, AI produces bloated SEO-optimized output…”
I find that a more human trait with writing.
People go on and on about nothing and have broken sentence fragments. AI tends to be "too clean".
I have ADHD and like en and em dashes. I've been known to use emoji points to make my 16 paragraphs easier to read.
Fortunately I think the constant personal tangents arr saving me
I get what you're saying, but I'll just clarify that my 16 paragraphs vs 16 words was about wordiness, not layout.
That's because you're probably not used to people from STEM areas who tend to be thorough rather than risk that some things might be mis- or not at all understood: the less one is sure about the level of knowledge or ability to keep up of those on the other side, the more thorough the explanation becomes.
Also the deeper you think about something the more elements there are to explain.
I have a STEM background myself and spent a good bit of my career writing (relatively poorly in my opinion) technical documentation. I understand what you're saying and I guess I didn't make my point very well.
I was hoping people would understand that I was referring to the enshitification of internet search results - where every search leads to pages of results of entire articles about very simple topics that say basically nothing. It seems obvious to be, though I admit I'm making an assumption, that the vast majority of these articles are LLM generated fluff attempting to lure people to pages to generate ad revenue.
TIL I'm an LLM.
It's not just true, it's a fact — we are all of us llms.
Thought I might be one too, until the "tangents and nonlinear storytelling" as evidence of being human and the scene from Megamind where he goes "being bad is the one thing I'm good at" came to mind.
meanwhile here i am with the silly three-em dash⸻too long to be used in most cases, so it's rarely used when training ai⸻and the two-em dash⸺not quite as absurd, but still pretty rare⸺and i keep on looking for weird characters to use regularly
This stuff can also pip up if AI was merely used to spellcheck.
This list would be wrong way too often dude
Not really. Spell check would only correct typos and grammar. It's still your style, your thoughts, your expression with the language.
If you're putting your whole essay into a AI tool, yeah... It's going to turn it into garbage with the list above. And that's on you.
AI is stupid and often does more than told, even if the text is short.
And replacing the hyphen would not be replaced
I thought it would be the semicolon, judging from the thumbnail. Now that would piss me off; I love semicolons, it would be unfair if they become the hallmark of LLMs.
I also appreciate the long dash but on mobile keyboard it's so awkward to find that nobody uses it for comments anymore.
Personally, I use the em-dash a lot, but I just type it as --.
Good luck, the next rounds of training will iron these out and the line will continue blurring. These tips will flag a lot of false positives from educated people, and those comments are valuable. Maybe if you look for human-style mistakes you will have hope determining if comment was made by a human, like capitalisation, autocomplete issues, and typos.
It's much easier spotting AI in photos, videos and probably audio.
You're right, they'll learn to disguise themselves perfectly over time. In this scenario, trusting strangers on the internet will be extremely risky and dangerous in the future if you know what I mean.
So just add this to your prompt to not do these things? None of the items listed can’t already be handled by existing LLMs.
I have done this with work stuff. Doesn't always work.
literally any tell will be fed back into the models to make them harder to detect, I wouldn't be surprised if this is already being automated