I disagree with the removal but you are wrong. Anti settler colonialism in Palestine use this argument of genetics and genealogical because those where exactly the main justification of Zionists forcing a state on the local Palestinians population. Many Zionists claim that they had has the right to create an ethnostate because of 2000 years old Jewish kingdom and continuous presence in the land while at the same time saying Palestinians are just Arab colonizers that should be transferred to other Arab countries while Israel take all the historical Palestine

Eeegh, This is not a clear-cut subject. While yes, a lot of us believe that one's genes shouldn't determine where one is allowed to live, we also can't dismiss the fact that historically Europeans felt very justified in forcefully going and settling lands where other people already lived because they felt they should just do so, and in the process exterminating the indigenous people and cultures. It's a more nuanced discussion that can be done in a few sentences, but I don't think it deserves a ban.

Do you feel the same about First Nations rights? About Ukrainians? Or does it just make you uncomfortable in the context of Palestinians? Are Indians from India? Or South Africans from South Africa? I fear you may have some implicit bias in play here.

One of the big false claims is that Palestinians are solely from the Arabian peninsula when that’s just unequivocally false. They’re indigenous to the Levant and it’s an important distinction to fight Zionist propoganda. Palestinians have the right to argue against being ethnically cleansed by stating their multigenerational ties to their home. Just like any First Nations people or other nationality. You’re concerned about weaponization of ethnonationalist rhetoric in a context where the power dynamics simply do not support such a concept.

Need to pick one: 'genetics' OR 'geneology' on this topic.

They're extensively different and blurring the two allows the discussion to pivot between them, which maximizes the potential for misconstruing points or taking them deliberately out of context.

You were right to call that trash out... these genetic clown discussions always end in one place lol

Funny how you got censored but person making the claims that would never fly in any other context did not. Not that i support censorship of either position. People should be able to discuss the issue freely.

Palestinians indigenous population to the land, I don't understand why genetic vector of argument is being used here at all beyond being dilatory on purpose.

I got banned on ML for calling American Jewish billionaires supporting Israel. bc NOT ALL JEWS 🤡

ML censorship has an interesting angle to it.