Rimworld

Randy is the only one that ever really gives me a good time. The others are too structured. Like, to the point with how much I've played I can easily predict what they will throw at me next. Randy, being totally random, keeps me on my toes.

I played quite a few under randy cause people swear by him but I feel I get a much more satisfying experience under Cassandra

Randy is too easy for me mid-game. Cassandra I got a bunch of difficult raids together with a nuclear winter as well as a cold snap that I barely survived.

With Randy I get a raid every now and then and a bunch of non-useful traders. On the same difficulty it is really too easy and doesn't allow me to grow my colony through captures as readily.

Randy or bust for me!

I'm intrigued by that mod that another commenter that mentioned a Cassandra and Randy combined though

There's a mod that's called "Randy and Cassandra". It gives you a new storyteller which is basically Randy and Cassandra at the same time. You will get twice as many events since you are running 2 storytellers, but the chaos can be fun.

I played through Randy once and I honestly like Cassandra more. I prefer the consistency of Cassandra over Randy's randomness.