There is still a load of administrative work to deal with, so there are needs for people to work there. How many depends on the bureaucratic overhead that would go into this new system.
No Stupid Questions
No such thing. Ask away!
!nostupidquestions is a community dedicated to being helpful and answering each others' questions on various topics.
The rules for posting and commenting, besides the rules defined here for lemmy.world, are as follows:
Rules (interactive)
Rule 1- All posts must be legitimate questions. All post titles must include a question.
All posts must be legitimate questions, and all post titles must include a question. Questions that are joke or trolling questions, memes, song lyrics as title, etc. are not allowed here. See Rule 6 for all exceptions.
Rule 2- Your question subject cannot be illegal or NSFW material.
Your question subject cannot be illegal or NSFW material. You will be warned first, banned second.
Rule 3- Do not seek mental, medical and professional help here.
Do not seek mental, medical and professional help here. Breaking this rule will not get you or your post removed, but it will put you at risk, and possibly in danger.
Rule 4- No self promotion or upvote-farming of any kind.
That's it.
Rule 5- No baiting or sealioning or promoting an agenda.
Questions which, instead of being of an innocuous nature, are specifically intended (based on reports and in the opinion of our crack moderation team) to bait users into ideological wars on charged political topics will be removed and the authors warned - or banned - depending on severity.
Rule 6- Regarding META posts and joke questions.
Provided it is about the community itself, you may post non-question posts using the [META] tag on your post title.
On fridays, you are allowed to post meme and troll questions, on the condition that it's in text format only, and conforms with our other rules. These posts MUST include the [NSQ Friday] tag in their title.
If you post a serious question on friday and are looking only for legitimate answers, then please include the [Serious] tag on your post. Irrelevant replies will then be removed by moderators.
Rule 7- You can't intentionally annoy, mock, or harass other members.
If you intentionally annoy, mock, harass, or discriminate against any individual member, you will be removed.
Likewise, if you are a member, sympathiser or a resemblant of a movement that is known to largely hate, mock, discriminate against, and/or want to take lives of a group of people, and you were provably vocal about your hate, then you will be banned on sight.
Rule 8- All comments should try to stay relevant to their parent content.
Rule 9- Reposts from other platforms are not allowed.
Let everyone have their own content.
Rule 10- Majority of bots aren't allowed to participate here. This includes using AI responses and summaries.
Credits
Our breathtaking icon was bestowed upon us by @Cevilia!
The greatest banner of all time: by @TheOneWithTheHair!
I live in Finland and we have free healthcare. I still have a life insurance and accident insurance. Most people I know do. I would get medical attention even without and wouldn't need to worry about going bankrupt but I don't feel like waiting for 4 hours with 30 other sick people to get to see a doctor so I spend the roughly 600 euros a year so that I can go to a private doctor. Free healthcare is not synonymous with good or efficient healthcare.
Then I obviously have insurances for my house, car, trailer, business and my retirement insurance so it's not like isurance companies have became obsolete.
You are going to love David Graeber's Bullshit Jobs. Based on the book, my guess is that the economy will probably bullshittize some more to absorb them.
They are parasites on our system, making profits and paychecks off human suffering. I hope they suffer when insurance goes away.
Untethering employment from healthcare would be an engine of liberty and prosperity. Imagine what people would chose to do if they weren’t paralyzed by fear of medical catastrophe.
Supplemental insurance will exist. Private insurance will be a luxury or more so and still exist. An army of administrators will be needed. Many people will lose their jobs or retire.
They can go fuck themselves, genuinely.
The work they are doing is not useful. They will have to learn how to do a useful thing. This is good because the world does not need people who operate a useless bureaucracy, but the world does need a lot of help in other ways.
They get decent health care.
Yes! Because it would no longer be tied to their employment! I'm certain that, as in many industries, some of them are doing soul-sucking work they hate just because they need the insurance coverage for themselves or a family member.
I would imagine a percentage go work for the new unified provider.
I grew up in coal/steel country and I knew more than a few older guys who were paid for job retraining when the steel mills closed. I’m not saying it’s the best idea but I think you couple that with paying to retrain people to work in the new system because it will still need people to administer the system.
Maybe, I’m no expert but it is something important to think about.
My dad took advantage if that when his tool and die shop closed down. He got a degree in social work and worked with mentally handicapped adults and loved it until he retired.
They will have to get jobs helping people instead of ripping off sick people
They find a different job subject to supply & demand of the labor market like everyone else.
Most of their skills translate to other jobs.
The resources freed up can go toward work more valuable to society.
Such resource reallocation is the creative destruction economists write about.
Will they need to close a datacenter that currently auto-rejects claims? Finally, someone asking the real questions.
It's so weird to me how much America has fucked the reputation of Insurance in the eyes of its own citizens
Insurance is actually a fair and affordable expense in most other developed nations, and actually a ready useful economic tool for individuals and wider society both
Corporations in America are just insanely greedy is all
I'm one of the few who have legal insurance. At $26 a month, it's saved me more over my divorce and custody cases than I will ever pay in. I can call in, leave a message with customer service, have a layer on the phone, for no additional cost, within an hour. BUT, there's only one company I know of doing it.
So yeah, insurance can be cheap and work for the people, not against us. But the ridiculous redundancy in our medical insurance systems is, most literally, killing us.
You're not wrong - eliminating insurance companies will also eliminate a lot of jobs. But it will also create jobs, and a subsequent shift of workers from corporate insurance to these new government roles. And government roles come with added benefits, like a pension and PSLF (student loan forgiveness). For those who don't end up working for the government, there are many other white-collar roles they can fill. Insurance jobs typically don't involve much in the way of specialized skills - an office job is an office job is an office job. There will almost certainly be a rough transition period when M4A is implemented, but I'm confident things will shake out.
It's always been noted, one private insurance will likely shrink. 2. Medicare itself will need more organizers, and people who worked there will be very good assets.
but bigger thing is... same kind of problem we always have isn't it? same issue with adding robot arms to assembly lines, and obviously what's happening to all forms of software development, what they claim will happen to driving and a dozen other career paths.
I don’t think that’s going to happen.
Medicare for all is a public option; not a replacement nor transitioning from one to another.
You can have public & private. Most countries have this option, most have public and don’t get private.
Getting private on top (friends experience in Montreal) of public in two examples:
Medical: you get access to small private clients, acts like a fast pass at Disneyland. Public hospital scheduled out 2+ months (like everyone else around the world; yes, same as private I. The US.), you can see private sooner because most people don’t use it.
Dental: you don’t waste your coverage on health related stuff, public covers it. You get cosmetic related stuff with private, like teeth whiting.
So since us Americans like (not all, obvi) fucking up our image, your private insurance is going to be used her because Medicare for all is just for your health.
Which is nice in the longer run, we should see at least 15% decease traffic in hospital/clinic because now you’re not waiting on someone getting a face lift or bugged out lips.
Edit: additional note: Yes, with the majority of people that will take the public option and private starts letting go employees; the government will already be offering training and hiring. Will we see lay offs before hand? You betcha because the private companies will try to save money as much as possible.
Kaiser Permanente Is a little different since they run and control their whole pipeline. They’re the Apple in medical.
There's loads more types of insurance than health insurance. The parasites will be fine.
With everyone covered there would be a larger demand for healthcare workers. Could also work for Medicare administration, and private insurance would probably still be an option too.
They'll be fine. M4A isn't a proposal to nationalize health insurance and won't remove profit incentives from the private sector. Currently, Medicare/Medicaid for some has for-profit companies as intermediaries between the government payer and the patients and physicians. They handle all the insurance part of the business, approving and denying claims, etc, and invoice the government for the premiums. Expanding, even universalizing, Medicare and Medicaid only increases their captive market of eligible beneficiaries and would likely be highly profitable.
M4A would probably set prices on the treatment options they offer and require the individuals to cover costs above that amount so there's a good chance that many people would still need private insurance for situations where the hospital they want to use is not covering the full cost of the procedure that they need based off of M4A.
So for like the average person, it generally means cost savings, whereas for people that are suffering from severe long-term issues like cancer or something may end up either being stuck in an eternal waiting queue or still having to purchase private insurance so that they can get their treatment faster.
There might not be as much redundancy as you think. The National system will have MORE customers than all the insurance companies combined because there is a large number of currently uninsured people.
More employees means faster and friendlier service. And no advertising budget means more employees. Industries crumble and leave people unemployed all the time, so even if they couldn't all get absorbed into the new system, they won't have to worry about getting sick while they find a new career.
Many of the rank and file administrative and office staff would transfer over to the equivalent government positions...but the sales staff and higher corporate positions would all be out of work.
Much of what I'm wondering about! Seems there would be a lot of positions eliminated over redundancy. And while the change goes through, those people will run to other jobs, if they can.
Most of the job losses will be those centered around the profit-driven aspects of the industry. Sales will be the most impacted, followed by the executive class. This is the primary reason why Medicare for all would save money...and also why so many politicians don't support it. That's a lot of jobs. But beyond that, the hit to inventors would be massive.
Depends on what that system looks like and how it is phased in to know how much or how little.
But yes, one of the actual issues in decommodification of things like this is that despite what capitalists will argue, it creates greater efficiencies so on net some people will be let go.
Personally that is why if I were benevolent dictator I would go the New Deal/China style route.
You couple things like M4ALL with additional industrial policy and investments that help absorb those sorts of shocks that left to just the capitalist market would result in concentrated and severe backlash combined with capital strikes and intentional overreactions and threats from the private sector.
In reality though I think America will just keep patchworking this shit heap of a system as we have done before and the question will be how well it gets patched up will come down to how much pressure the left can build up. Same way the New Deal happened.
Presumably private health insurance would still exist for the ultra wealthy
Private insurance isn't going anywhere. Either some combo or pricy option.
Some or all of these would likely happen.
- minimal layoffs as most insurance companies transition to contractors with Medicare to process claims.
- private health insurance is still somewhat common for a significant number of people as Medicare has significant gaps.
- Medicare advantage style plans become widely available to everyone.
- insurance company doctors have to start actually practicing medicine.
- government run rural hospitals would be a new source of employment.
- Medicare would need significantly more staff to handle more than doubling the number of insured.
- insurance companies have significant layoffs as they downsize to running the hospitals and pharmacies that they own, maybe something like a PBM still exists as well.
Thoughts and prayers
Half of them will be paid to break windows, and the other half to fix them. That way they can stay employed.
Supplemental private insurance would probably still be available. So the industry as a whole would still exist. Probably not enough to totally avoid people losing their jobs.
The same thing exists with the tax filing industry here.
Not only this, many of those jobs as handlers and adjusters would be absorbed into Medicare as it scales up.
But really, this is about trimming bloat. So asking this question is much like, "But what will happen to all these people we're paying to dig holes in the desert?" If roles were reversed and this was a private industry issuing mass layoffs, the capitalist answer would be, "Just trimming fat. Pull yourself up by the bootstraps and adapt!"
That first bit is part of what I'm asking and have no idea how that plays.
For example, we've debated locally whether to combine the city and county governments. Seems like a cost savings, no brainer. But, for example, we'd still need the same number of people approving construction plans.
Seems there's so much redundancy in insurance that a load of people will be left out in the cold. Most Americans want this thing, but we need a plan for those folks.
Businesses and industries have shut down before. This isn't a new phenomenon. Retraining, employment in related fields (how specialized do you think healthcare IT is?), doubtless unemployment for a while for some people, early retirement for others. The same thing that happens when Microsoft lays off a bunch of people or DOGE closes a bunch of government organizations.
I mentioned it in some thread ages ago. It's going to be really bad on the resources and tax incomes of certain towns/cities where the medical industry is one of the main employers. There will not be enough jobs to go around which will strain resources a lot in those areas. Unemployment is handled by each state, so that may factor into things as well and potentially make it difficult for people. Look at what happens in places like West Virginia when a mine closes; whole towns get hit. That's a failure of the government to take care of people in situations like this. And, yes, I know some of them voted for that, but I'm not OK with hurting people who didn't.
Edit: I spent years working in US healthcare IT
because insurance co's have company towns?
M4A is not replacing doctors or anyone else that actually provide care. just the insurance companies.
Company towns, no, but some places have economies that are heavily skewed toward medical jobs.
There are a lot of people who would be out of the job, though. A lot of IT roles would evaporate. When you only have to deal with one insurance company, a lot of EDI and integration jobs are gone. Other jobs that have to deal with doing things for multiple providers are gone (which includes non-IT jobs). Less IT work means fewer support staff and resources there as well which is more jobs gone (though a bonus for the environment).
There are still more jobs that would go as well. Yeah, it's all useless when suddenly everything becomes one insurer which, in itself, is a good thing, but there will be a lot of people all looking for work at once.
Company towns, no, but some places have economies that are heavily skewed toward medical jobs.
Most insurance providers aren’t physically located near the hospitals. So that’s not a significant issue.
Again, M4A doesn’t remove actual health care providers. It removes the barriers to them.
As for other roles like IT and support… I don’t think you have good enough numbers on that to say one way or the other.
And that’s beside the point that they can still probably find other IT jobs, or whatever field they’re in.
Sorry, but worrying about a small subset of people’s jobs to resolve an issue that affects literally everyone in the country is absurd.
If it comes to that, we can put them to work doing something actually useful rather than supporting inflationary middlemen who make money denying necessary healthcare to Americans.
I don’t think you have good enough numbers on that to say one way or the other.
As someone who worked in IT specifically in integrations with insurers, labs, and other healthcare facilities, I think I do have a good basis there. I also have several family in other parts of the healthcare industry in the US, both clinical and non-clinical staff.
And that’s beside the point that they can still probably find other IT jobs, or whatever field they’re in.
Yeah, ask people in IT how their job searches are going lately, particularly with companies getting rid of remote work.
Sorry, but worrying about a small subset of people’s jobs to resolve an issue that affects literally everyone in the country is absurd.
You've missed my point. I want universal healthcare in the US; I moved to a country that has it in part for that reason. The OP's post talks about the other side effects this would have, not about not doing it.
If it comes to that, we can put them to work doing something actually useful rather than supporting inflationary middlemen who make money denying necessary healthcare to Americans.
What jobs? Where are these jobs? How are they being trained? What about the people who can do desk work (I've known coders (as in ICD-10 not computer code) who were bed-bound. What is happening to all the businesses (restaurants, cleaners, and anything else) in these areas that no longer have customers? You can be mad at the US healthcare system all you want (I am and shit-talk its inefficiencies and inhumanity all the time), but why are you so anxious to punish the people who need work even if they aren't related at all directly to the system?
I used to work at an insurance company as IT too, a BIG one. Yes, a lot of people will be out of work; IT, developers, finance people, janitors, security, and all those thousands of other positions that dont all have anything to do with insurance, just jobs that support it. I still think it should be done, but, there will be an impact. A lot of them can be transitioned over as government employees, but, there will be local hits. Idk what the solution is, but, you're not wrong. Like I said, it should still be done
It could be an issue that needs to be addressed. It won't happen quickly though, and maybe other jobs that are related will open up. But we definitely should not put a shift to a better system to protect the jobs that might be affected when so many more people, including those same job holders, will be helped.
Didn't say this was an excuse not to change! But real people, and a shitload of them, will be hit. And not just people working in insurance, people in related fields.
They'll look for another job. Hopefully something better for humanity this time.