Buzzword bullshit. Sound and music involve the manipulation of sound waves. You were never a researcher or a teacher. "Resonance of electricity and light"....lol!
guitars
Welcome to /c/guitars! Let's show off our new guitar pics, ask questions about playing, theory, luthier-ship, and more!
Please bring all positive vibes to the community and leave the toxic stuff elsewhere.
Rules:
-
Treat others with respect. ALL others.
-
No spam
-
No self promotion
-
No NSFW
-
No circle jerk posts, there are other places for that silliness, and they are wonderful. Not here.
This sounds cool but the lack of precision in the details makes me question if you're trolling or high.
So how do you describe the physical contruction of this thing? Pick whatever physical dimensions and frequencies as you want, but don't give me "you can't hear it because it's light and it's frequency is yadda yadda". Tell me what I should see in a scope and or fft analyser and what equipment do I need to plug the instrument into a scope/etc.
This seems awesome, glad to hear your chasing your interests!
Thank you!
What an incredibly cool and interesting concept!
Cool sound. I'm curious about the instrument version of it and why that isn't a pursuit. Is it weird to play? Are you just trying to target a larger market?
Thanks! I’ve started with the plugin version of the photonic guitar as it provides the greatest flexibility for musicians and requires the least development resources. The instrument version itself is also a pursuit but there are challenges. First, we can’t directly hear the results. On top of that the instrument operates roughly a million times faster than an acoustic guitar. We just can’t play fast enough. It is possible to overcome the time difference and plug an electric guitar into a photonic guitar and play it that way but that requires some fancy equipment. The required fancy equipment needs to be designed and built first, but it is possible.
Naturally the photonic guitar uses coaxial cables for strings that resonate electrically based upon cable length. In principle we could build a guitar neck to physically play but that leaves the time difference and hearing issues.
Thanks for the question.
Can you elaborate a little more on the instrument. It's electricity resonating in a coaxial cable and length changes the note? Why does that affect the speed of playing? We also can't move at the speed of sound (I know it's much slower than electricity but still much faster than humans) but we're able to play a guitar that works on sound principles.
Sure, I can try. Let’s back up a bit. First, I made the photonic guitar the same size and shape as an acoustic guitar so we’d get a similar physical response. While many resonance equations are typically written as a function of frequency it is really the size of the wave relative to the object that physically matters. Since the speed of light is roughly a million times faster than sound, the frequency range where light is the same size as the sounds we hear is a million times higher. 20 Hz - 20 kHz sound waves becomes 20 MHz - 20 GHz light waves.
The second part is the time response of a musical instrument can be described by ADSR, attack, decay, sustain, and release. Attack is the initial response of the instrument to a new note which then decays into the instruments sustained response as the note is held. Eventually the response ends, or releases. Suppose I measure an acoustic guitar’s ADSR at a particular frequency. While this would typically be expressed in time, it is physically more descriptive to express each portion of ADSR relative to the period, or the time for one cycle, of the test frequency.
We know acoustic guitars are good for music so a photonic guitar with the same ADSR as an acoustic would also be good for music. Let’s just consider one part, sustain. Suppose the sustain for an acoustic is 1000 periods at our test frequency. The photonic guitar equivalent wave at the same size has a frequency a million times higher, thus the time of a 1000 period sustain is a million times shorter. 1 second of music in our time is equivalent to 1 millionth of a second in photonic guitar music time.
So you've constructed the photonic guitar and you're able to play it, but the pitch is up about 13 octaves and it has functionally no sustain? (Edit: and that makes us unable to hear any playing.) Is there any way to refract the signal or something to make it travel a longer distance inside the same space?
And one other curiosity, how do you play it? How do you "pluck the string"?
And thanks for chatting, this is wicked interesting!
We can’t hear the photonic guitar because the music it creates is in the form of light waves. In absolute frequency the waves are also pitched high compared to our audio range. In musical terms though they are the same pitches and octaves as produced by an acoustic instrument. We can’t see the photonic waves either as the frequencies are too low for that. Plus the visual range doesn’t even cover an octave. The timescales are also too short so there’s a variety of reasons.
The ADSR was my attempt to use a physical example to motivate why the timescales are shorter for the photonic guitar. The photonic guitar has plenty of sustain relative to the timescales that its physical size sets.
You can use dielectric type materials to vary the wave speed within the photonic guitar.
Strings are plucked using an electrical impulse. This sucker’s electrical.
In practice though the instrument is played by using math and guitar measurements.
Thanks for the questions.
If you can get it to an electric signal, why can't you just put it through a transformer that would allow it to plug into a guitar amp?
Edit: would a transformer be able to change the octave?
It is in general possible to bridge between the two but requires custom and specific hardware.
thats a really nice sounding recording, well done
Thank you!
Edit: double posted so adding more info. The guitar and bass are first recorded direct and clean, no effects. We take these clean signals and re-record with the plugin played through a fender amp. I use both an sm-57 and r121 in to a focusrite scatlett. Drums are software. A recording engineer does the mix and master.
Cool.
Thanks!