There's a huge array of roguelikes that might fit your wants.
Video Game Suggestions
A place to find suggestions for video games! For example, you might create a post looking for recommendations for a game to play with a friend, or a game that is easy to play if you just broke your dominant hand. Or you might post a list of games that let you use a whip as a weapon. A lot of rules for conduct here are pretty obvious (don't be a jerk, stay on-topic) so I'll bold the weird ones.
Rules
- Please stay on-topic: post requests for games that match some criteria you specify, lists of games with a certain element, or something otherwise relevant to helping people find games that match certain criteria.
- If you're looking to find the name of a particular game or video game series you forgot, you should go to !TipOfMyJoystick@retrolemmy.com. This community is for fielding suggestions for games, not for finding one specific video game.
- If you're making a post that is suggesting games, it should be a list of games. This is partially to help prevent the community from being overrun by people just suggesting their favorite game, and devs suggesting you play their latest game. This is about posts, not comments. It's okay to comment on a post asking for gaming suggestions with just one game.
- Don’t be a jerk. This covers bigotry and discrimination, which includes but is not limited to homophobia, racism, sexism, etc.
- Please don’t directly link to pirated content.
- When advertising something you have worked on, please use common sense for what is spammy. Self-promotion isn't totally banned: if someone asked for an RPG where you can play a lich, and the game you worked on is an RPG where you can play a lich, you can definitely answer with your RPG. I reserve the right to change this rule to be more specific about what exactly counts as spammy and what does not, but I feel I’ll know it when I see it and trust most posters to operate in good faith.
- Please indicate spoilers when necessary. The following format works on both Lemmy and Kbin, but if you are using an app it may not. See this comment for which apps handle spoilers. Note that spoilers in post bodies will just show the text in the preview if you link the post in, say, Discord, instead of spoiling it.
Spoilers for SomeGame
Something that happened at the end of the game!
Something else that happened at the end of the game!
will appear as
Spoilers for SomeGame
Something that happened at the end of the game!
Something else that happened at the end of the game!
Not Rules
Magazine/community icon is the Apple video game emoji and green checkmark emoji for now. Suggestions for a replacement are very welcome.
Roguelikes came to mind for me, too. Some of them are basically "what if Donkey Kong kept going forever, but also you held onto some powerups, even after a game over. Oh and Donkey Kong sometimes talks to Mario about the existential nature of failure."
The two I've played the most:
- Dead Cells
- Hades
Was thinking just that. Somehow, Enter the gungeon entered my mind. But then also Hades, because it has such good storytelling
In Dicey Dungeons, you do turn-based battles by rolling dice and assigning them to your moves, which are tiles that fit on a grid. There's a set of storylines about a bunch of characters who have been turned into anthropomorphic dice.
Just Shapes and Beats is a rhythm-bullet hell hybrid where you dodge graphical patterns set to electronic music. You play through a campaign, including boss fights and goofy animated cutscenes, to unlock more tracks in free-play mode. There's also co-op!
Ash & Adam's GOBSMACKED is a single-player arena FPS. You battle robots in a series of arenas with a set of wacky weapons, with shops in between. At the start of each run, you have to buy yourself a starting loadout using the money you got from previous runs, but you can't choose the same items as your last run. Buying an item for the first time at a shop unlocks it so you can choose it as a starter in a future run.
If you're willing to stretch your definition of arcade-style, Uncle Chop's Rocket Shop has you repairing spacecraft with the help of an old manual but plenty of things kill you, including not making enough money to pay rent. You go through a time loop story where you take what you learned in the previous loop to make it further next time. There are different endings based on what you did in a loop.
The Rogue Prince of Persia. Other rogue-like games would probably work, too.
Another chance for me to talk about Chrono Ark? Sure why not.
I don't know if roguelike deckbuilder falls under your scope of arcade-like, but Chrono Ark has absolutely amazing gameplay combined with a full fledged visual novel between (and occasionally during) runs. And the story is actually quite interesting, and takes some turns you don't see coming and touches on some pretty interesting themes.
Cannot recommend it enough.
Castle Crashers is an oldie, but goodie.
As others have said, look into the Rogue-like genre. (And also Rogue, itself, if that's your thing.)
I feel that Rogue Legacy and Rogue Legacy 2 deserve some mention here, for being essentially Mega-Man gameplay, but perfected.
In particular, Rogue Legacy 2 has difficulty sliders that can make it extremely arcade-like, such as maxing out both player and enemy damage, to make every encounter a one-hit kill.