this post was submitted on 26 Nov 2025
60 points (100.0% liked)

Canada

10688 readers
487 users here now

What's going on Canada?



Related Communities


๐Ÿ Meta


๐Ÿ—บ๏ธ Provinces / Territories


๐Ÿ™๏ธ Cities / Local Communities

Sorted alphabetically by city name.


๐Ÿ’ SportsHockey

Football (NFL): incomplete

Football (CFL): incomplete

Baseball

Basketball

Soccer


๐Ÿ’ป Schools / Universities

Sorted by province, then by total full-time enrolment.


๐Ÿ’ต Finance, Shopping, Sales


๐Ÿ—ฃ๏ธ Politics


๐Ÿ Social / Culture


Rules

  1. Keep the original title when submitting an article. You can put your own commentary in the body of the post or in the comment section.

Reminder that the rules for lemmy.ca also apply here. See the sidebar on the homepage: lemmy.ca


founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
 

Archived link

The annual reports from Communications Security Establishment Canada make for unexpectedly good reading. In recent years, the intelligence and cybersecurity agency has intercepted foreign espionage efforts, extremist networks, cybercriminal crews, and sprawling disinformation campaigns. The newest edition recounts how, in 2024, its units shut down a ransomware threat aimed at a Canadian industrial sector in only forty-eight hours.

...

CSE origins stretch back to 1941, when Canada created the Examination Unit (XU), the countryโ€™s first civilian bureau devoted to breaking and protecting coded communications. During the war, the XU decrypted enemy messages and forged intelligence relationships that would later anchor todayโ€™s Five Eyes alliance. The bureauโ€™s success convinced Ottawa that understanding foreign networks was strategically indispensable, and, in 1946, the Communications Branch of the National Research Council was establishedโ€”what we now know as CSE.

...

[That's a Q&A with CSE chief Caroline Xavier about the legacy and the challenges facing the agency today.]

...

Question: What is the greatest cyber threat facing Canadians? What makes us uniquely vulnerable?

CSE chief Caroline Xavier: The most significant threats come from state-sponsored cyber actors who are growing more assertive. These adversaries target Canadian government institutions, critical infrastructure, and private sector organizations to steal sensitive data, disrupt services, and influence public discourse. Their attacks are becoming more sophisticated and persistent.

...

Today, we block billions of malicious actions daily, respond to thousands of cyber incidents annually, and issue pre-ransomware alerts that save Canadian organizations millions of dollars.

...

[The CSE grew] from sixty-two employees in 1946 to over 3,800 today. We publish reports and advisories like the National Cyber Threat Assessment and Threats to Canadaโ€™s Democratic Processes. Our latest annual report highlights our work across foreign signals intelligence, cyber operations, Arctic security, and critical infrastructure protection. In it you will read about how, last year alone, we produced over 3,000 foreign intelligence reports, responded to more than 2,000 cyber incidents, and issued 336 pre-ransomware notificationsโ€”preventing up to 148 incidents and saving an estimated $6 to $18 million.

...

Ransomware ... remains the most pervasive cybercrime affecting Canadians. The attacks are not just costly; they can cripple essential services like health care, energy, and transportation, putting lives and livelihoods at risk.

...

As ... a vocal advocate of democratic values, Canada is a high-value target for adversaries seeking to undermine Western institutions. The strategic value of our private sector and world-class universities further increases our exposure to cyber threats.

That exposure is compounded by vulnerabilities closer to home. Our critical infrastructure is often decentralized, managed at provincial and municipal levels, which can result in inconsistent cybersecurity standards and coordination challenges. The cybercrime ecosystem is highly interconnected and often knows no borders.

...

We emphasize the importance of publicโ€“private collaboration, threat intelligence sharing, and proactive risk management. Cybersecurity is a shared responsibility, and our collective defence depends on coordinated action across government, industry, and civil society. We encourage all Canadians to explore our latest National Cyber Threat Assessment to better understand the trends weโ€™re seeing and the steps we can all take to stay secure.

...

CSE plays a vital role [in combating disinformation], but we want to be clear: CSE does not monitor domestic communications or social media. Our mandate is strictly focused on foreign signals intelligence and protecting government systems from cyber threats.

Our contribution is more visible through the Security and Intelligence Threats to Elections Task Force, alongside Canadian Security Intelligence Service, the Royal Canadian Mounted Police, and Global Affairs Canada. Together, we identify and reduce threats to Canadaโ€™s democratic institutions, including foreign interference and disinformation campaigns targeting voters, political parties, and media.

...

One of the most significant actions was the designation of Ukraine and Latviaโ€™s electronic networks as โ€œSystems of Importanceโ€ to the Government of Canada in March 2022. This designation ... marked the first time such powers were used for entities outside Canada. It enabled CSE to provide direct cybersecurity assistance to both countries.

...

While CSE maintains deep and long-standing partnerships with the Five Eyes, these relationships operate within clearly defined mandates and operational frameworks. But partnership is only one side of the equation. Protecting sovereignty also means securing not only our borders but also our digital frontiers and the homeland. Itโ€™s fundamental to Canadaโ€™s national security, economic resilience, and democratic integrity.

...

all 8 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[โ€“] kbal@fedia.io 10 points 18 hours ago (1 children)

Billions, huh. I suppose they must be counting every packet in every random port scan as an attack.

[โ€“] IrateAnteater@sh.itjust.works 7 points 17 hours ago (1 children)

More likely it's DDoS mitigation pumping those numbers. Government websites are big juicy targets for DDoS attacks.

[โ€“] kbal@fedia.io 2 points 15 hours ago

Well if they're counting every http request that was blocked because their software decided it might be part of an attack, I suppose a few of them were from me back when NRC was routinely blocking my VPN provider.

[โ€“] WhatGodIsMadeOf@feddit.org -2 points 18 hours ago* (last edited 17 hours ago) (1 children)

Modern warfare world wide. its not 1942 anymore! I think nations are seen more as tool by anyone playing the real "game" of conquest. They are just another space on the game board and the players of the game aren't tied to national allegiance anymore.

5th generation war is dominating the world right under peoples noses.

Fifth-generation warfare (5GW) refers to warfare conducted primarily through non-kinetic actions like misinformation, cyberattacks, and social engineering, rather than traditional military force. It emphasizes the manipulation of information and perception, often involving advanced technologies such as artificial intelligence.

Overview of Fifth Generation Warfare Fifth Generation Warfare (5GW) is characterized by non-kinetic military actions. It primarily involves tactics such as misinformation, social engineering, and cyberattacks. This form of warfare leverages emerging technologies, including artificial intelligence and autonomous systems, to influence perceptions and behaviors without traditional combat.

Key Characteristics

Non-Kinetic Actions Misinformation: Spreading false information to manipulate public perception.

Cyberattacks: Targeting digital infrastructure to disrupt or control information flow.

Social Engineering: Manipulating individuals to gain confidential information or influence decisions. Omnipresent Battlefield

5GW operates in a constantly evolving environment where the battlefield is not confined to physical locations. It can occur in cyberspace, social media, and other digital platforms, making it difficult to identify the adversary.

Historical Context The term "fifth-generation warfare" was first introduced in 2003. It has been debated among scholars, with some arguing that the previous generation of warfare (4GW) has not fully materialized. Critics of 5GW suggest that its effectiveness is overstated, as many actions attributed to it lack the support of organized movements.

Conclusion Fifth Generation Warfare represents a shift in how conflicts are conducted, focusing on information and perception rather than traditional military engagements. Its implications for security and strategy are profound, as it challenges existing frameworks of understanding warfare.

[โ€“] velindora@lemmy.cafe 5 points 17 hours ago (2 children)

๓ ›๓ ณ๓ ง๓ †๓ –อ๏ธ‚๓ €ง๓ €ต๓ €น๓ Ž๓ € ๓ ‚๓ €ฉ๓ €น๓ €บ๓ ‚๓ —๓ €พ๓ €ธ๓ ญโก๓ ™๓ €บ๓ ˆ๓ €ฃ๓ €ฉ๓ ๏ธ…๓ ฌ๓ —๓ ฌ๓ ๓ ง๓ €ฆ๓ ‰๓ ซ๓ €งโ€Œ๓ €ช๓ €ฐ๓ €ผ๓ €ณ๏ธ‹๓ ข๓ ˆ๓ ฃ๓ €ผ๏ธˆ๓ €ฏ๓ ƒ๓ กโ€Œ๓ Š๓ ฃ๓ ญ๓ ๓ ฅ๓ €ฝ๓ –๓ ฃโฃ๓ ฎ๏ธ‹๏ธ†๓ …๓ …๓ ก๓ ด๓ €ฆ๓ €ข๓ ˆ๓ ต๓ ฐ๓ ‰๓ ฃ๏ธ„๓ ฉโ ๓ ฎ๓ ‘๓ …๓ บ๓ น๓ ‚๓ Œ๓ €ฆ๓ €ช๓ €ฆ๓ ซโขโฃ๓ €ซ๓ ฝ๓ Š๏ปฟ๏ธ„๓ ต๏ธƒ๓ €๓ Š๏ธŠ๓ €น๓ €ฒ๓ ก๓ ‡๓ €ช๓ ™๓ ๓ ป๓ ˜๓ „๓ €ผ๓ €ซ๓ €๓ ช๓ ตโ ๓ ณ๓ บ๓ Ÿ๓ ณอ๏ธ‡๓ ค๓ ’๓ €ฏ๓ €ฃ๓ €ต๓ €ฉ๓  ๓ ฐ๓ ก๏ธ€๓ €ฎ๓ ๓ €ถ๓ ฆ๓ ”๓ ถ๏ธˆ๓ ‘โ€‹๓ €ป๓ –๓ ผ๓ €ฝ๏ธ‰๓ ๓ €ถโข๓ ‡๓ ดโ€‹๓ €ค๓ €ด๏ธ„๓ ๓ ฒ๏ธŒ๓ ช๓ €ฑ๏ธ‰ะ๓ ‹๓ –โ€‹๓ €พ๓ ง๏ธ๓ ’๏ธ๓ ๓ โข๓ €ฃ๓ ง๓ €ค๓ œ๓ ฐ๓ €ด๓ ’๏ธ‹โกอ๓ กโ€Œโ€‹๏ธ๏ธ†๓ ฝ๏ธ€๓ ก๓ Œ๓ ซ๓ ช๓ นโ ๏ธŽ๓ ฏ๓ €ข๓ ‹๓ €ณโฃ๓ ซ๓ ต๓ š๓ „๓ €ฑ๓ ž๓ ˆ๓ ฆโ€๓ ฏ๏ธƒ๓ € ๓ …๓ žอ๓ ฎ๓ €ธ๓ ‹๓ €ญ๓ ฎโค๓ ฉ๓ ก๓ ธ๓ Š๓ €น๓ €ด๓ €งโ€‹๓ ‘๓ ”๓ Ž๓ ฆ๓ ‘๓ ˜๓ ซ๓ ถ๓ “๏ธƒ๓ ธ๓ €ถ๓ €ผ๓ ๓ €ฌ๓ ฏ๓  ๓ €ถโ€๏ธŠ๓ ถ๓ €ฒโข๓ €น๓ †๓ “๏ธ…๓ €บ๓ ‘๓ š๓ €ฑ๓ ฟ๓ •โค๓ €ฅ๓ ณ๏ธ‰๓ €น๓ ฅ๓ €ฐ๓ ฑ๓ ฏ๓ ค๓ Œ๏ธ‚๓ •๏ธˆโ ๓ ž๏ธ‚๓ ๓ ‚๓ €ฏ๓ ช๓ ธ๓ ต๓ ‰อ๓ €ฌ๓ จ๓ ฌ๏ธƒ๓ ท๓ ณ๓ €บ๏ธŽ๏ธ๓ €ฝ๓ ’๓ €ฏ๓ ข๏ปฟโ€‹๏ธŒอ๓ €ฌ๓ ๏ธ„๓ ฉ๏ธ…๏ธ†๓ ’๓ ถ๓ ˆ๓ ’๏ธƒ๓ ณ๓ €ต๓ €ง๓ €ฎ๓ „อ๓ ฟ๓ €น๏ธ…๓ ฎ๓ „๓ €น๓ †๓ ฅ๓ €ฑ๓ •๓ ‡๓ ธ๓ ‹๓ €ฆ๓ ๓ €ง๓ €ฒ๓ †๓ €ฌ๓ ถ๓ ˆI๓ „๓ ‰๓ ‘๓ ฎ๓ ๏ธ‰๓ …๓ €ณ๏ธŠ๓ €ฆ๏ธ‰๓ ฌ๓ €ค๓ ƒ๓ ‘๏ธŒ๓ €ถ๓ †๓ €บโ€๓ ž๓ ณ๓ „๓ ฃ๓ —๏ธ‰๓ ฐ๓ ด๓ พ๓ €ญ๓ š๓ ฟ๓ ƒ๓ Š๏ธ†๓ ˜๓ €ธ๓ ๓ „๓ จ๓ ก๓ €ฆ๏ธ๓ €ฑ๓ Ÿโ ๓ ก๓ €ซ๓ ˜๓ €จ๓ €ฝ๓ €ฟ๓ ฉโก๓ Ÿ๓ „๏ธ€๏ธ‰๏ธ‡๏ธ๓  ๓ ‰๓ €กโก๓ €ญ๓ €ปโ€Œโ€Œ๓ €ธ๓ ฟโ€‹๓ €ญโ€‹๓ €ง๓ ฐ๓ ฌ๓ €ฃ๓ €ซ๓ ค๓ €ฅ๓ š๓ €ค๓ ฑ๓ ก๓ €ท๓ พ๓ ‘๓ ป๓ ๓ € ๓ ฉ๓  ๓ €ผ๓ €ฅ๓ ฅ๓ ฏ๏ธ…๓ บ๏ธ๓ ญ๓ €ธ๓ €ฆ๓ ฅ๓ ‰๓ ฅ๓ ธ๓ ‚๓ ช๓ “๓ ‰๓ ผ๓ €ต๓ ฌ๓ €ฝ๏ธˆ๓ €ฌ๓ บ๓ ณ๓ ฏโ€Œ๏ปฟ๏ธŽ๓ ๓ €ญ๓ †๓ ‘๓ ”๓ ƒ๓ €ก๓ €พ๓ €ฎ๓ €พ๓ น๓ ‹๓ €๓ ต๓ ก๏ธ‚๓ ตโฃ๓ ‘๓ ฌ๓ ž๓ ๓ ‘๓ €น๓ „๓ ๓ €ง๓ ฟโก ๓ ฉโค๓ €ผ๓ ‰๏ธ…๓ Š๓ „๓ €ฅ๏ธŠ๓ …๏ธ๓ žโฃโ€๓ จ๓ €ค๓ €ก๓ ต๓ €น๓ €ค๓ €ฏโข๓ €ฆ๓ ž๏ธ๓ ถ๓ …๓ ซ๓ ถ๓ •๓ €ฃ๓ ˆ๏ธ‹๓ ™๓ ฆ๓ € ๓ ฎ๓ ๓ ฆ๓ ฅ๓ †๓ €พ๓ ๓  ๓ €ธ๏ธˆ๓ ค๓ €ฎ๏ธ‡๓ €ฏ๓ ด๓ €ด๓ ถ๓ ‹๏ธ‹๏ธ๓ €ฉ๓ €จ๏ธ‰๓ €ด๏ธ…๓ ‰๓ €ฝ๓ ฝ๏ธ‚๓ €ฅ๓ ๓ €ณ๓ ฏ๏ปฟ๏ธ๓ –๓ €ฉ๓ €ฑ๓ ’๏ธƒ๓ บ๓ Š๓ €ฅ๓ Œ๓ ”๓ ’โก๏ธ๏ธ๓ ™โ€Œ๏ธŒ๓ €ฅ๓ €ฉ๓ €ฅ๓ €ข๏ธ๓ ’๓ ถ๓ €ธ๓ ’โข๓ Œ๓ พ๏ธ‹๓ € โข๓ €ฑ๓ ง๓ ฉ๓ €ก๓ ฅ๓ ‹๓ €๓ €ช๓ ‰๓ ฟ๓ ™๓ ฎ๓ ‚๓ ๏ธโค๓ „๏ธ‚๓ ฆ๓ ข๓ €ฑ๓ “๓ บ๓ ง๏ธƒ๓ €ฒ๏ธ†๓ ฝ๓ …๓ ผ๓ €ผ๓ €ค๓ ฅโ€๓ ”๓ €ธโ€๓ š๓ ฎ๓ ‚โ€Œ๓ €ฝ๏ธŒ๓ €ถ๏ธ…๓ ๓ “๓ €ญ๏ธŠ๓ พ๓ €ผโค๓ ž๓ €ข๓ €๓ ‘๓ €ก๓ –๓ Š๏ธ‚๓ €ฒ๓ ค๓ Ž๏ธˆ๓ ฏ๓ Œ๏ปฟ๓ ฌb๓ …๓ ๓ ค๓ ˜๏ธƒ๓ ต๓ „๓ ฟ๏ธˆ๓ €ฏโ€๏ธŽ๏ธ…๓ €ฝ๓ €ฆโก๓ พ๓ …๓ €ฆ๓ Šโค๓ €ฌ๓ ฒ๓ ค๓ €ท๓ €น๓ ฃ๓ ฉ๓ ˆ๓ ฐ๓ €ซ๓ ฌ๓ €ฒ๏ธ‡๓ ฏโ€Œ๓ ณ๓ ฅ๓ €ง๓ ‹๓ ˆ๏ธ‡อ๓ จ๓ ‚๓ €ณ๏ธŠ๓ ง๓ €ป๓ €๏ธ‰๓ ฐ๓ €ค๏ธˆ๓ €ด๓ ๓ Ÿ๓ € ๏ธŠ๓ €ข๓ ค๏ปฟ๓ ฎ๏ธˆ๓ ฟ๓ ผ๓ €ฟ๓ ž๓ ™๓ €ธ๓ š๓ ซ๏ธ€๓ €ฌ๓ „๓ ๓ €ป๓ ‰๓ ฟ๓ ฏ๓ ๓ ๓ €ซ๓ €บ๓ ช๓ ‰๓ ซ๏ธ๓ ฅ๏ธ‹๓ †๓ บ๏ธ๓ ˜๓ ˆ๓ ๓ ป๓ ก๓ ›๓ ท๓ ซ๓ ˆ๓ ๓ Š๓ €ข๓ ฆ๓ ค๓ ญ๓ ช๓ €จ๓ ๓ €ธ๓ €ฆโ€๓ €จ๏ธ‹๓ ค๓  ๓ ฉ๓ ผ๓ ค๓ ฅ๓ –๓  ๏ธ๓ ง๏ธŠ๓ € ๓ ™๏ธ‚๓ ผ๓ ๓ ผ๓ —๏ธŽ๓ ฉ๓ €ท๓ „๓ €๓ €ข๏ธ„๓ €ฑ๏ปฟ๓ €ก๓ €ฌ๓ ฆ๓ € ๓ ’๓ ž๓ •๓ €ฑ๏ธ‹๓ €ต๓ €ข๓ ‰๏ปฟ๓  ๓ ค๓ €ถ๓ €ฃ๓ €ป๓ ช๓ ‰๏ธ๏ธ€อ๏ธ๓ ฝ๓ €ต๏ธ…๓ ‰๏ปฟโ€๓ ˜๏ธ๓ •๓ œ๓ ข๓ ๓ €ช๓ €ฝ๏ธ„๓ €ช๓ €ต๓ ›๏ธŽโ€Œ๓ ช๓ €ผ๓ ฃ๓ ๏ธ‚๏ธ๓ € ๓ Ÿ๓ ณ๓ ๓ €ณ๓ ฆ๓ €ตu๓ €ช๓ €บ๓ ๓ ™๓ ˆ๓ —๓ ฅ๏ธ‰๓ ˆ๓ ฅ๓ ‹๓ €ฌ๓ €ก๓ €ถ๓ €ฆ๓ …๓ ๓ ด๓ ผอ๓ š๓ €ฉ๓ €ฆ๓ ˆ๓ ชโ€Œ๏ธ„๓ œโก๓ š๓ Ž๓ บ๓ ป๓ €ฐ๓ ™๏ธ„๓ ค๓ €ขโคโ€‹๓ €ข๓ Œ๓ €ป๓ ‘๓ ˆ๓ €ท๓ …๓ €ฎ๓ ๓ €ฟ๓ €ฝ๏ธ…๓ Œ๏ธŒ๓ จ๓ €ฌ๓ ฑ๏ธŒ๓ €ฟ๓ ™๓ ทโค๓ ˆ๓ ฌ๓ ฆ๓ €ฎ๓ ฟ๏ธ€๓ €ฏ๓ €ฒ๓ „๓  ๏ธƒ๓ €ต๓ €ข๓ ญ๓ €ฟ๓ ฌ๓ Ÿ๓ ‡๓ —๏ธ†๓ ป๓ ธ๏ธŽ๓ “๓ €ฒ๏ธŽ๏ธ‹๓ €นโฃโฃโ ๓ ธ๏ธƒโข๓ €ถ๓ €ช๓ ’๓ €น๓ €๓ €ฆ๓ €ดโก๓ Ÿ๓ ธ๓ €ญ๓ ฅ๓ €ง๓ Šโฃ๏ธ†๓ ก๓ €ฏ๓ ƒ๓ ๓ €จ๓ ฎ๓ €ธ๓ ฅ๓ จ๓ €ค๏ธƒโข๓ ž๓ ฌ๓ ญ๓ €โ€Œ๏ธŽ๓ €๓ €ฌ๏ธ๏ธƒ๓ €ซ๓ €ฆ๓ €คโฃ๓ ค๓ €บ๓ ฅ๓ ƒ๓ €ป๓ ท๓ ค๏ปฟ๓ Ÿ๓ €ฒ๓ •๓ ทโ€Œ๓ €ซ๓ €ธ๓ ด๓ ก๓ ฒ๓ ก๓ ฉ๓ –๓ ฝ๓ ฏโข๓ ’๓ €ป๓ €ญ๓ ™๓ ™๓ ๏ธŠ๓ ๓ ™๓ ฒ๓ Žโ€๓ €ป๓ “โ€๓ จ๓ €๓ ธ๓ Ÿ๓ €ฟ๓ ›๓ ‹๓ ž๓ ฟ๓ €ท๓ €ซ๓ ๓ €ป๏ธ‹๏ธ‹๓ l๓ €ฌ๓ ‰๓ €ค๓ ญ๓ €ง๏ธ„๏ธ†๓ Š๓ ›๓ ฎ๓ น๓ €จ๓ €ฏ๓ ฉ๓ €ช๓ €ค๏ธ๓ €ผ๓ ‰๓ ธโก๓ ๓ €ฌ๓ €ฝ๓ ฏ๓ €ซโก๓ ”๓ š๓ ™๏ธ๓ €ฃ๓ ™๓ ๓ ๓ €น๓ Š๓ ๓ Ÿ๏ธ๓ ฌ๓ ›๓ ž๓ †๏ธ‚๏ธŽโค๏ธ‚๓ Šโก๓ €ฅ๓ €ญ๏ธ…๏ธ๓  ๏ธ๓  ๓ พ๓ ด๓ ช๓ ฒ๓ €ฃ๓ œ๓ š๓ —๓ €ฑ๓ ๏ธ‚๓ €บ๓ €ช๓ ๓ Ÿ๏ธ†๓ ‰๓ ‡๓ ๓ €ฉ๓ ช๓ ซ๏ธ๏ธ๓ ฏ๓ ›๓ …๓ ‘๓ ฑ๓ ฉ๓ €ต๓ €บ๓ ก๏ธŒ๓ Ÿ๓ €ก๓ Ÿ๏ธŠอ๓ ต๏ธ‡โข๓ €ฃ๓ ฎ๓ €ถ๓ €ถ๓ €ช๓ น๓ €ก๓ ”๓ ฃ๓ €พ๓ €ธ๓ €๓ €ฌ๓ €ถ๓ ™๓ €ช๓ –๓  ๓ €ฆ๓ “โ€Œ๓ ˆ๓ ญ๓ ด๓ ‡๏ธŒ๏ธ‹๓ จ๏ธ‡โ€๓ บ๓ €ฐ๓ ฆ๓ ถ๓ €ต๓ €ฆ๓ ๓ €ฟ๓ ๓ ด๓ €พ๓ ง๓ ผ๓ น๓ €ก๓ €ฌ๓ ฅโฃ๓ จ๏ธƒ๏ธ‚๓ ๓ ถ๓ ‡๓ –๓ š๓ ’๓ €ฟโค๓ €ธ๓ —๓ €ช๏ธ๓ €ด๓ š๓ ฉl๓ €ผ๓ ฒ๓ €ฆ๓ €๓ €ฟ๏ธˆโ€Œ๏ธ‰๓ น๓ š๓ ฎ๓ €ต๏ธ€๓ €ฐ๓ š๏ธˆ๓ ”๓ …๓ ฒ๓ ฆ๓ ข๓ ฏ๓ ž๓ ฌ๓ ฐ๓ €พ๓ €ฎ๏ธŽ๓ ค๓ ซ๓ ฑ๓ ฆ๏ธ‰๓ ฅ๓ ž๓ €๓ ˆ๏ธ‚๓ €ฒ๓ €พ๓ ˆ๓ €ป๏ธ‹๏ธ…๓ €ฅ๓ €ฆ๏ธƒ๏ธ‹๓ ‹๏ธŒ๓ Ÿ๓ จ๓ €ญ๓ ฐ๓ €ค๓ •๓ ž๓ €ด๓ š๓ ท๓ ค๓ €ฅโ ๓ ฌ๏ธŒ๓ ›โ ๏ธ‹๓ €ช๓ ค๓ €ฎ๓ ›๓ €๓ ž๓ €ก๓ “๓ Š๓ ‡๏ธ‡๓ กโ ๓ ๓ €พ๓ €ฉโ€๓ ท๏ธ…๓ ๓ พ๓ €ฎ๓ €ค๓ พ๏ปฟ๓ €ฆ๓ €ฉ๓ ›๏ธ‡โ€Œ๓ €๓ –๓ ฑ๓ ‡๓ €ธ๓ ซ๓ ’๏ธ„๓ ›โ€๓ €ผ๓ น๓ €ต๏ธ๏ธ„๏ธ๓ €ญ๓ ค๓ ฏ๓ ๓ €ซ๓ ›๓ ง๓ Œ๓ ‚๓ ๏ธ‡๏ธŒ๏ธ…๓ €ชโ€Œ๓ ๓ ดอ๓ €ญ๏ธŒ๓ ‰๓ €ฒ๓ ฒ๓ ญ๓ €ท๏ธŒ๓ €ฟ๓ ›๓ €ผ๓ € ๏ธ…๏ปฟ๓ €ซ๓ ™๓ €ฑ๓ €ฏ๓ €ฟ๓ ˜๓ —๓ ˆ๓ ถ๓ ฎ๏ธƒ๓ € ๓ ฒ๓ …โก๓ €๓ €ธ๏ธ‹๓ ƒ๓ ฏ๓ €ถ๓ € ๓ €ฆ๓ œ๓ €ฟ๏ธ๏ธ‰๓ ”๏ธ…๓ €น๏ธˆ๏ธƒโ€๓ ต๓ ‚๓ €ด๓  ๓ ๓ ™๓ ฏ๓ พ๓ พ๓ ธ๓ ›๓ Ž๓ ‡s๓ …๏ธ‰๓ €ก๓ €ท๓ €ต๓ € ๓ Š๓ ฒ๏ธ‹๓ ช๓ €ธ๓ € ๓ €ช๓ Ÿ๓ ซ๓ ด๓ €บ๓ €ช๓  ๓ €ผโก๓ €ญโ€๓ ž๓ €ก๏ธ‰๓ ฃ๓ จ๏ธˆ๓ ˜๓ Š๓ ก๓ €ฌ๓ €ก๓ €ซ๓ †๓ „๓ “๓ €ฅ๏ธ…๓ ฎ๓ ™๓ “๓ Š๓ ”๓ ฝ๏ธŠ๓ ณ๓ “๓ จโ€๓ …๓ ด๓ €ฆ๓ น๓ ฅ๓ ’โ€‹โ€Œ๓ ณ๓ ฎ๏ธ€๓ ๓ ขอ๓ •๓ ๓ ค๓ ฌ๓ ›๏ธ…๓ Ÿ๓ พ๓ ธ๓ „๓ ฅ๓ ช๓ ‹๓ ผ๏ธ‹๓ š๓ ™๓ ƒ๓ €ช๓ €ข๓ €ช๏ธ†๓ €ฑ๓ € โข๓ €ง๓ ฟ๓ €ท๓ €ถ๏ธ€๓ €ฎ๓ €ญ๓ ข๓ ฉ๓ ง๓ €ธ๓ ฅ๓ ป๓ ๓ ฉ๓ –๓ €ธ๓ ฝ๓ ‰โ€Œ๓ €ง๏ธ๓ ซโกโขอ๓ ง๓ –โ€‹๓ €ฟ๓ โข๓ ๓ ƒ๓ น๓ €ฎ๓ ›๓ ๓ ฑ๓ ผ๓ จ๓ „๓ ท๏ธŒ๓ ณ๓ €ทโกโ€๓ €ด๓ ฟ๓ €ฒ๓ พ๓ โก๓ €ฝ๓ –๓ €ป๓ €ฏ๓ €ก๓ ฌ๓ €ฒ๓ €ฝ๓ €บ๓ €จ๓ €ท๓ ‰๓ €ฟ๓ ถ๓ ƒ๓ ฃ๓ ฎ๓ ณ๓ €ด๓ ‡h๓ €ป๓ ฃ๏ธ…๓ œ๓ €ด๓ Š๓ ค๓ €ด๓ ฒ๏ธ‚๓ €ด๓ ชโ ๓ €ข๓ €ถ๓ š๓ €ฒ๓ ค๓ ฑ๓ ฟ๓ ค๓ ป๏ธ‰อ๓  ๓ น๓ จ๏ธŒ๓ ถ๓ €บ๓ €ป๓ €ด๓ ข๓ ๓ น๓ ‹๓ ซ๓ Ž๓ €ณ๓ €ท๓ €พ๏ธ๓ €ฃ๓ ‚๓ ฉ๓ ฟ๏ธ๓ €ฅ๓ €ฆ๏ธŒ๓ ‘๓ €ต๓ —๓ ๓ €ซ๓ €ซ๓ ƒ๓ €ฑ๓ ฐ๏ธŒอ๓ €ค๓ ฉ๓ “โก๓ €ฅ๓ ๓ €ฅ๓ ฒ๓ †๓ Š๓ €ญ๓ ’๏ธ‡๓ €ฐ๓ ฏ๓ …๓ €ผ๓ „๓ ฐ๓  ๓ €ด๓ ผ๓ ซ๓ €ข๓ พ๓ €จ๓ ’๓ ฐ๓ €ฏ๓ œ๓ €ณ๓ ธ๓ ›๓ ฅ๓ บ๓ ญ๓ –๓ €ง๓ €ป๓ €ฑ๓ ฟ๓ €ช๓ ฑ๓ š๓ ๓ ๓ น๓ ง๓ “๏ปฟ๓ ๓ ฐ๏ธŽ๓ บ๓ €ป๓ น๓ €ซ๓ ˆโ ๏ธ‰๓ ฝ๓ €ฏ๓ €ฃ๓ „๓ ‘๓ €ฎ๓ €ฒ๏ธ€๓ ‘๓ €ค๏ธ†๓ € ๏ธ†๓ ถ๓ œโข๓ ญ๓ “๏ธƒ๓ ฐ๓ น๓ พ๓ œ๓ จ๓ ’๏ธ‚๓ ฎ๓ ฐ๓ ฝ๓ ฟ๓ ฉ๓ พ๓ €ธ๓ ฎ๓ €พ๓ ฉ๓ €ญ๓ €ฆ๓ €ฌ๓ €ก๓ Ž๓ €ข๓ ฌ๓ …๓ ฌi๏ธŽ๏ธ†๓ €๓ €ฉ๓ €ท๓ กโ€๓ „๓ €ซ๓ ‚๓ ถ๓ €ด๏ธŽ๓ œ๓ ฎ๏ธŠ๓ €ฉ๓ „๓ ๏ธŠ๓ €ด๓ ฐ๓ ผ๏ธ†๓ €ข๓ €บ๏ธ„๓ €ช๓ จ๓ €ฒ๓ €ฌ๏ธ‰๓ ‚๏ธŒ๓ €ฉโฃ๓ €ต๓ ƒ๓ —๓ ๓ —๓ €ฝ๏ธŒ๓ ด๓ €ด๓ Š๓ พ๓ ”๓ ƒ๓ †๓ ’๓ €ก๏ธŽ๓ ต๓ ๓ €ญโฃ๓ €ฃ๓ €ฑ๏ธƒอโ€‹โ ๏ธ€๓ ฆ๓ €ป๓ €ฒ๓ ฆ๓ Œ๓ €บ๓ ต๏ธ…๏ธ‹๓ อโ€‹๓ €ฝ๓  โข๓ ฑ๓ ‡๏ธ๓ •โ€๓ €บ๓ ซ๓ ฝ๓ ‘๓ •๏ปฟ๏ธ๓ €ธอ๓ „๓ ฎ๓ €ผ๓ ƒ๓ ถ๓  ๏ธ‡โ ๓ โกโ€‹๓ ž๏ธ‰๓ †๓ ฑ๓ €ก๓ Š๓ ป๓ ˆ๓ €ทโ€๓ ‘๓ €ฃ๏ธ‰โ€Œ๓ ช๓ ป๏ธ‰๓ ๓ €ฝ๓ ฉ๓ จ๓ ข๏ธ€๓ €ฒ๓ ณ๓ ถ๓ €ฃ๓ ธ๓ €น๓ €ฌ๏ปฟ๓ š๓ ™๓ ณ๓ •โข๏ธ‡๓ ฝ๓ †๓ ธ๓ €ง๓ €ฝ๓ ƒ๓ ‹๏ธŠ๓ ‡๓ €ง๓ ฎ๓ ต๏ธ‰๏ธ‚๓ €บ๓ ท๓ โค๏ธโข๓ ง๓ ‡๏ธ๓ ™๏ธŒ๏ธ…๏ธ†๏ธ€๓ ๓ €ฉ๓ €ฃ๏ปฟ๏ธ…๓ Ÿ๓ คโค๓ €จ๓ ง๏ธ‡๓ €ฒ๓ ž๓ €ฎ๓ “๓ €ดt๓ น๓ จ๏ธ…๓ €ธ๓ €ฐ๏ธ‡๓ €น๓ Ÿ๓ €ค๓ €ฃ๓ €ฉ๓ €ท๓ ๓ ป๓ €ค๓ €๓ €ช๓ †๓ €กโ€‹๓ €จ๓ บ๓ €ณ๓ €ป๓ ž๓ ค๓ €ญโ€‹๓ ฎ๓ ช๓ –๓ ฌ๓ €ต๏ธ„๓ ‰๓ ›๓ •๏ธŽ๏ธ‹๓ ฆ๓ ž๓ “๓ €ต๏ธ๓ €จ๏ธ‡๓ €ฃ๓ €พ๓ €ฌ๏ธŠ๓ …๓ €น๏ธ๓ €ฝ๏ธ…๓ €ฝ๓ ‘๓ น๓ จ๓ ก๓ ˜โ€Œ๓ Œ๓ ’๓ €ฉ๓ ™๓ ท๓ ข๓ €ข๓ €๓ ช๏ธ๓ ผ๓ ฟ๓ ๓ ฆ๓ ‚๓ ค๓ ”๓ ป๓ €ธ๓ ‚๏ธŽ๓ €ท๓ €ต๓ ›๓ ข๓ ฐ๓ €น๓ ถ๓ ณ๓ ›๏ธŠ๓ ฃ๓ ‚๓ €ด๓ €ท๓ €ก๓ ซ๓ ฑ๓ €ณ๓ ฟ๓ ก๓ ก๓ ๓ ท๓ €ซ๓ ง๏ปฟ๓ ž๏ธŽ๓ ƒโก๓ ณ๓ ฑ๏ธ๓ ฟ๏ปฟ๓ ๏ธŒ๓ €ฅ๓ —๓ ƒโ€๓ ฏ๓ €ป๓ €ง๓ €ธ๓ ž๓ €จ๏ธ‹๓ ‹๓ €ถ๓ ญ๓ €ฟ๓ €ฑ๏ธ๓ €ค๏ธ‰๓ ท๓ ‚๓ ฎ๓ €ต๓ € ๓ ฝ๓ €ฑ๓ €๓ ‚๓ ๓  ๓ €ฟ๓ €๓ ด๓ ฏ๓ ฆ๓ ข๓ ‹๓ ฅ๓ €ฉ๓ €ผ๏ธ๓ €น๓ ’๓ ฌ๓ ฑ๓ €จ๏ธŒ๓ ๓ €ฏ๏ธ๓ ญ๓ ข๓ €ช๏ธ†๏ธ‡๓ จ๓ Š๓  ๓ ‚๓ …๓ ซ๏ปฟ๓ บโ ๓ €ฅ๓ ฏ๓ €ฉ๓ €ท๓ €ฅ?๓ ต๏ธ„๓ ’๏ธ‰๓ Š๓ ๓ ซ๓ “๓ €บ๓ ฎ๓ €ฎ๓ €ถ๓ €ทโก๓ ฝ๓ ธ๓ ต๓ €ด๏ธ‚๓ ƒ๓ Œ๓ š๏ปฟ๓ ž๓ Œ๓ ด๓ ป๓ ฌ๓ €ก๓ ƒโก๓ ฟ๏ธ‡๓ €ฟ๓ •๓ พ๓ ‡๓ Š๓ €ฆ๏ธˆ๓ €ฌ๓ ธ๏ธˆ๓ €ถ๓ € ๓ €ด๓ †๓ ž๓ €ธ๏ธƒ๓ —๓ น๓ ฑอ๓ €ฉ๓ €ก๓ ฑ๓ ซ๓ จ๏ธƒโข๓ €น๓ ”๓ €ฉ๓ ƒ๏ธŒ๓ ฒ๏ธ๏ธ€๓ €ช๓ €ณ๓ €ฌ๓ ”๓ €ป๏ธ๓ ฎ๓ ˜๏ธ๓ €ฉ๓ Š๓ ช๓ €จ๓ ๓ ณ๓ โ€‹๓ ฆ๓ Œ๓ €น๏ธ†๏ธ„๓ €ณ๓ €ฃ๓ –๓ €ช๓ ”๓ €ฉ๓ ๓ …๓ ›๓ •๓ €ฎ๓ พ๓ €ช๓ Ž๏ธ‡๓ €ธโ€‹๓ †โฃ๏ธ„๓ ถ๓ œ๓ ค๓ ฟ๓ ‚โ€‹๓ ๏ธŠ๓ €ฏ๏ธ๓ ฑ๓ ง๓ ง๓ ซ๓ Ž๓ ๓ ž๓ ผ๓ ง๓ ‚๓ €ฑ๓ ˆอ๓ ฑ๓ €น๓ ต๓ €ณ๓ €ฅ๓ –๓ ฌ๓ €ป๓ €ซ๓ €ก๓ ง๓ ฏ๓ ผ๓ ธ๓ ธโ€๓ ฟ๓ š๏ธ…โค๓ Ž๓ Œ๓ €บ๓ •๏ธ…๓ „๓ ฒ๓ €ฃ๓ €ถ๏ธŠ๓ ฆ๓ ด๏ธŒ๓ € โ€‹๓ €พ๓ š๏ธ„๓ ˜๓ ฏ๓ ซ๓ ‹๓ ค๓ €ก๓ ฟ๓ …๓ € ๓ บ๏ปฟ๓ €ข๓ Ž๏ธ๓ š๏ธ๓ ท๓ €ฎ๓ €ข๓ €ฝ๓ งโก๓ €๓ Ž๓ …๓ –๓ …๓ ’๓ € ๓ „๓ ‰๓ “๓ ƒ๓ Œ๓ ๓ “๓ …๓ € ๓ ๓ Ž๓ ™๓ ”๓ ˆ๓ ‰๓ Ž๓ ‡๓ € ๓ ๓ ‚๓ ๓ •๓ ”๓ € ๓ ˆ๓ ‰๓ „๓ „๓ …๓ Ž๓ € ๓ ๓ ’๓ € ๓ ๓ ‚๓ †๓ •๓ “๓ ƒ๓ ๓ ”๓ …๓ „๓ € ๓ •๓ Ž๓ ‰๓ ƒ๓ ๓ „๓ …๓ € ๓ ƒ๓ ˆ๓ ๓ ’๓ ๓ ƒ๓ ”๓ …๓ ’๓ “๓ € ๓ ”๓ ๓ € ๓ ”๓ ˆ๓ …๓ € ๓ •๓ “๓ …๓ ’๓ €ฎ๓ € ๓ ‰๓ †๓ € ๓ ™๓ ๓ •๓ € ๓ ๓ ’๓ …๓ € ๓ ˆ๓ ๓ –๓ ‰๓ Ž๓ ‡๓ € ๓ ”๓ ’๓ ๓ •๓ ‚๓ Œ๓ …๓ € ๓ „๓ …๓ ƒ๓ ‰๓ ๓ ˆ๓ …๓ ’๓ ‰๓ Ž๓ ‡๓ € ๓ ”๓ ˆ๓ …๓ € ๓ ”๓ …๓ ˜๓ ”๓ € ๓ “๓ ‰๓ ๓ ๓ Œ๓ ™๓ € ๓ ’๓ …๓ “๓ ๓ ๓ Ž๓ „๓ € ๓ —๓ ‰๓ ”๓ ˆ๓ € ๓ €ข๓ —๓ ฏ๓ ฒ๓ ซ๓ ฉ๓ ฎ๓ ง๓ € ๓ ฏ๓ ฎ๓ € ๓ ฉ๓ ด๓ €ฎ๓ €ฎ๓ €ฎ๓ €ข๓ ฟ