this post was submitted on 03 Apr 2025
7 points (100.0% liked)
Perth / Western Australia
563 readers
6 users here now
Below are some resources for Perth/Western Australian info that could help find the perfect story for that exceptional post.
Suggestions to add to the list are very welcome!
This community wishes to be about all things Perth/WA, not just latest news. Whether its memes, dreams, or custard creams! Tell us your Western Australian story! π¦
Local News/Lifestyle
The Urban List
University, TAFE and Related
Notre Dame
Miscellaneous
Brendan's Odyssey
Government/LGA
WA.Gov, announcements
Department of Biodiversity, Conservation, and Attractions
WA Podcasts
Wild WA Podcast
Occasional WA Focus
Renew Economy
ABC WA
ABC WA
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Oh for fuck sake.
If a child drowned at swimming lessons, that would be an absolute tragedy... but mandating some kind of safety device, with the outcome being fewer kids receive swimming lessons, is obviously going to increase the risks to kids.
Bike helmet laws are also demonstrably a huge self-own for public health. All the data we have shows very clearly that helmets don't reduce the severity of injuries and impede a cycling culture.
I've been hit by a car, and even with a helmet, I had a bump on my head (which is why the ambos who attended managed to convince me eventually to come hospital for 5 hours). My skull would have been cracked open if it wasn't for the helmet. My brother was hit on his motorcycle in a hit and run too.. He's lucky he survived at all. It's awesome even when ducking branches and such
It's not impeding cycle culture at all. Literally takes 2s to put on a helmet.. how is that impeding anything?
Your advice will kill people.. Anyone who has ever fallen off a bike knows this.. Try running on gravel in bare foot if you want to get an idea of just how effective helmets are. Please don't spread bullshit like this. You can even get MIPS helmets which further improve the safety
That being said, Chain and sprocket guards, I have no issue being made mandatory on new bikes (at least so there is a transition period). But, just checking amazon, they actually seem to be cheap anyway. So maybe not a big issue (but, not sure how badly people are struggling these days)
Terrible idea. Maybe you could mandate it on children's bikes, but absolutely not on all bikes. Sports cyclists would murder you if you tried to do that.
There will always be a small number of people that complain.. People also complained about seat belts..
In reality, I suspect very few people would care otherwise
If you consider that on a lot of other types of races there is mandatory equipment too which changes, I don't think they'd care, provided that it affects all of them equally. At an olympic level or national level, maybe different, but otherwise, doubtful..
There are even people complaining that helmets "are less safe" right now. It's really a nothing issue once bikes have them by default
Yes, but you have to weigh the benefit against the costs. Seatbelts are a no brainer because there's literally no downside to mandating them.
Helmet laws have already proven problematic because of how they have proven to reduce how many people cycle, which reduces people's life expectancies...by more than the traumatic injury caused by a crash without a helmet would. Things that make cycling more difficult for people, even by a tiny amount, are detrimental to public health and should be seriously scrutinised.
Chain and sprocket guards...what would be the benefit of them? The WA government has already reversed their rule about schools requiring them after it turned out they never intended it to have as big of an impact as it did. And to be frank, the safety benefit of them seems likely to be quite small. Maybe for children it could be worth it, but I have never heard of an adult receiving an injury that would have been prevented by a chain and sprocket guard. Meanwhile, it would make doing routine maintenance of your bike a much bigger hassle than it currently is, and maintenance is required to keep a bike in good working order.
It's such a non-factor that chain and sprocket guards basically don't exist for road bikes. There are a couple of extremely niche products out there that do it, but they're not exactly a standard off-the-shelf product you'd find at your local 99 Bikes. That should be a pretty strong indicator that mandating them is not really the way to go.
Uh, sorry, but that's just not true. The data we have show very clearly that, as an individual decision, wearing a helmet is absolutely a good idea.
When it comes to public policy, other factors like participation rates come into play and are worth discussing, but not the individual impacts.