this post was submitted on 22 Mar 2025
11 points (86.7% liked)
The Onion and other satire w/ layers
585 readers
251 users here now
For posting satire from The Onion and other similar sources.
redundancy, but not for its own sake
founded 8 months ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Honestly, fuck isGlitch. They have no idea how to construct satire. Half the headlines would not stand out on The Register, and the rest usually fumble a decent premise. They desperately need an editor.
The silliest part of this is simply true, and the punchline is just dumb. The premise is 'all that power, and they still can't [trivial thing]?' Except "Not Hot Dog" was famously a real thing, a decade ago. HBO defictionalized that specific trivial thing. They would be better-off with a cheap reference like "still can't tell why kids love Cinnamon Toast Crunch."
Crossposts show a bunch of people taking this seriously, which is a sign that you failed at satire. It's not "eating the onion." This is the hellscape we live in, and the absurd elements invoked are plausible. Do something about replacing firetrucks with Cybertrucks. They're a free laugh and you can suggest they're never far from a raging inferno.
This one's good. No notes.
Revise, revise, revise. A punchline needs to hit. You already used "thought" at the start, so it can't be the reveal. Also that's not what thoughtcrime means. You could almost reference facecrime by saying it censors based on typing, like if you linger too long after "I think Elon should". Banning based on what you type and delete is sadly plausible.
This reads like an actual thing. And it's purple as hell. Scrap it and reach for the absurd: "Tesla offers giant Groucho Marx glasses to disguise cars." "Model S owner makes engine noises with mouth to fool nearby drivers." "Ashamed Tesla driver seen charging parade float." "Conversion kits disguise Cybertruck as less-embarrassing Oscar Meyer Weinermobile."
Again, "deadly" can't be the second word and the punchline. This is aiming for the absurdity of "Deadly Super Rainbow Tears Through West Coast" but whiffs. (Honestly that Onion classic could've been rearranged.) And the study killed six? The study generated traffic? This should be about a FEMA cleanup effort, or saying people were "buried alive."
Absurd beyond belief: check. Humorous: not so much. It's not great at first blush, and it doesn't get better as you think about it. They already take everyone's art. If anything OpenAI would want people coerced into drawing, so they have more to scrape.
Punchline goes at the end.