Anarchism

It must be windy that high up in your soapbox.

Standing on a soapbox is still much better than having your head in the clouds.

I don’t mean to tell you, but the world order completely changed after WW1 and WW2

Sooo... these collapses you speak of - I'm assuming absolutely none of them resulted in the liberal socio-economic being any less resilient and dominant than it actually is today?

Last time I checked it certainly hadn't.

I'm not sure what point you are even trying to make by defining these crises as "collapses."

because people are too propagandized to perform said radical change

So the propagandised working class is to blame for the left's abysmal failures, eh?

Okay... let's assume that is the case - just for the moment. The first question that comes to my mind... how is the left's counter-propaganda theory and praxis coming along, then?

Over the last decade (or so) I've seen lots of (so-called) "debunking" media on libtube... oops, sorry, I meant to say breadtube - and even some of it here on lemmy - which, as any competent propagandist can tell you, is essentially useless for waging a war of narratives.

If I were to ask any (self-described) radical on lemmy to explain liberalism to me - which is where any competently thought out counter-propaganda narrative (ie, one that acknowledges the working-class' actual political experience) would start off from - using only one, succinct sentence... would any of them be able to manage that?

If the answer is "not many can do this extremely basic thing" then... you have a problem - it would be extremely premature to blame the working class' propagandisation for the left's failures if it were to turn out that the left is hopelessly incompetent at counter-propaganda.

And yes - before you ask - my background is in propaganda.

Lots of libertarian leftists (including, of course, anarchists) assure me that they do, in fact, listen to Bakunin's proverbial bootmaker... but I'm not seeing all that much of it.

Would you like to modify your statement, perhaps... and blame the left's failures on something else?