A place to share alternatives to popular online services that can be self-hosted without giving up privacy or locking you into a service you don't control.
Rules:
Be civil.
No spam.
Posts are to be related to self-hosting.
Don't duplicate the full text of your blog or readme if you're providing a link.
Submission headline should match the article title.
No trolling.
Promotion posts require active participation, with an account that is at least 30 days old. F/LOSS without a paywall has exceptions, with requirements. See the rules link for details. Tags [CBH] or [AIP] are required, see the links in Rule 8 for details.
AI-related discussions and AI-involved promotional posts have additional requirements for tagging, as noted in Rule 7 and the AI & Promotional Post Expanded Rules post, and find example disclosures here.
Resources:
Any issues on the community? Report it using the report flag.
Questions? DM the mods!
Lots of varied advice in the thread. I would suggest you choose a software first, then find recommended naming for it. Many will do some organisation for you, or even let you define the structure.
I don't like calibre, but it's undeniably the most complete solution. I'm not a fan of having to remote into a desktop for certain actions that given frontent doesn't support (there are many).
Some other options: https://selfh.st/apps/?tag=Books
I use BISAC
I've been using Grimmory for nearly a year now and it's been great at organising and applying metadata to my poorly organised collection. I dumped all my books into it and let it structure and order the directories. There was a little work to do to verifying the metadata it pulled, but I now have my whole family using it to find and read ebooks.
Its OPDS support also lets me use Moon+ Reader on my phone to browse and read my collection.
Grimmory sounds like a new kid on the block, and indeed, it is. I've looked into it, and here's what I've come up with:
With all that in mind, I think I'll give this project a pass for now. Like you said, it's some work that goes into curating a library and making sure the metadata is correct, and if that locks me into a project that may or may not exist several months or years from now, I'll probably stick to one of the more established projects with a higher likelihood of long-term maintenance.
It's a fork of a Booklore which was closed back in March. Grimmory is the spin-off by a group of the original developers. So while the repo and project are relatively new, the codebase and lineage is not. I've found it to be stable and reliable since I switched from Booklore.
A Booklore fork! Yes, that does make sense, since Grimmory's commits oddly start with v 2.x.x
It does not, however, change my outlook much. Booklore, too, was a very young project (initial commit: March 2025) and heavily vibecoded by a handful of people.
I don't organize by folders, I use tagging so a single book can be in multiple categories at the same time.
That sounds reasonable. So you're essentially throwing everything into one folder and let software do the rest? May I ask what software you're using, and how it stores your tags? Does it use metadata files or a database?
Forget about folders. Use a good metadata schema.
Feel free to elaborate. ;) I don't mind ditching folders. The question is: how do I get at said metadata with the least amount of manual effort, how do I make sure that it's accurate (sifting through thousands of files is not fun), and how is the metadata stored - particularly so that does not lock me into one application that can only understand its own metadata scheme, and once it dies or I want to switch to a different one, I lose all the work I've put into curating my collection. That's why I was considering folders as an option: they are a software-agnostic way of organising my library.
I use calibre Web automated (CWA). I don't concern myself much with the filesystem level structure, but it's author/work + metadata for other details.
If you start making the fs the sorting mechanism, you end up with books that don't belong anywhere or have too ma y categories. I"be been down that road.
I highly reccomend using calibre.
bonus points if you use a self hosted LLM to auto catalogue and apply metadata to the file before importing into calibre.
the recent openweight models are surprisingly good at reading files, pulling info, and doing simple monotonous tasks thousands of times without failing.
Hi there,
thanks for not staying true to your username. ;)
[let the LLM] apply metadata to the file
How does this work in practice? I've got a bunch of .pdf, .epub, .txt, even some .doc files lying around in a folder. What would an LLM do to them? Write a bunch of .xml files with a file name identical to the corresponding book, or what?
I've not personally tested such stuff (as my setup is complete and I did the metadata all by hand before the age of LLMs), but to my understanding; the LLM is able to write opf/XML/whatever files you want for metadata, or even edit the file directly to add metadata. epubs and PDFs support author/title/etc tags iirc, so its not too hard to get the LLM to apply those after ingesting the text and searching online for matches.
I shitpost a lot in comments, making shitposts is lame and for losers. better to actually say meaningful things with a post rather than a nothingburger shitpost xD
I tried the dewey decimal system for a while, but that got real tedious. An inbetween platform seems a better solution to this than folder organization, but I haven't looked into that yet. Keeping my eye on this thread for sure!
Same as I do for music. I use Calibre and do a lot of manual organization. My tree looks like this:
King, Stephen/
Christine/
Christine.epub
Dark Tower, The - 01 - Gunslinger, The/
Dark Tower, The - 01 - Gunslinger, The.epub
Dark Tower, The - 02 - Drawing of the Three, The/
Dark Tower, The - 02 - Drawing of the Three, The.epub
Needful Things/
Neefdul Things.epub
Of course, most of my books are fiction so I don't use genres, but now I'm rethinking that lol.