Could it be a imperial bolt and you need to use a 3/16 because imperial to metric doesn't match up exactly?
Bike Repair Tips and Tricks
For bicycle repair tips and tricks, as well as questions, mostly in picture form, from all over the web.
I think between your comment and everyone else saying to try a 5.5, this is most likely it. Only other idea is that the holes are wallered out, but a slightly larger key and a hammer should fix that.
Ooh good info. That might be it!
Edit: is that in inches? If yes I guess that’s less than 5mm right? But maybe the next size up is in between 5 and 6
Somewhere between 3/16th inch and 1/4 inch.
The numbers are usually millimeters, try searching for a 5.5mm Allen key.
Lots of results when I search but no idea what country you're in so pointless me sending any links.
Could it be a 5.5? Or a 5 plus a big elastic band maybe?
5.5mm Allen wrenches are a thing, are popping up with my basic internet search.
Are you sure it's a hex and not a Torx? T30 Torx is approximately between 5mm and 6mm IIRC.
Yes pretty sure it’s a hex one!
Torx bit might work too. I often use those when I don't have a hex set at hand. Or try the 5mm key but shim it with a rubber glove. Or file down a 6mm one.