Trans
General trans community.
Rules:
-
Follow all blahaj.zone rules
-
All posts must be trans-related. Other queer-related posts go to c/lgbtq.
-
Don't post negative, depressing news articles about trans issues unless there is a call to action or a way to help.
Resources:
Best resource: https://github.com/cvyl/awesome-transgender Site with links to resources for just about anything.
Trevor Project: crisis mental health services for LGBTQ people, lots of helpful information and resources: https://www.thetrevorproject.org/
The Gender Dysphoria Bible: useful info on various aspects of gender dysphoria: https://genderdysphoria.fyi/en
StainedGlassWoman: Various useful essays on trans topics: https://stainedglasswoman.substack.com/
Trans resources: https://trans-resources.info/
[USA] Resources for trans people in the South: https://southernequality.org/resources/transinthesouth/#provider-map
[USA] Report discrimination: https://action.aclu.org/legal-intake/report-lgbtqhiv-discrimination
[USA] Keep track on trans legislation and news: https://www.erininthemorning.com/
[GERMANY] Bundesverband Trans: Find medical trans resources: https://www.bundesverband-trans.de/publikationen/leitfaden-fuer-behandlungssuchende/
[GERMANY] Trans DB: Insurance information (may be outdated): https://transdb.de/
[GERMANY] Deutsche Gesellschaft für Transidentität und Intersexualität: They have contact information for their advice centers and some general information for trans and intersex people. They also do activism: dgti.org
*this is a work in progress, and these resources are courtesy of users like you! if you have a resource that helped you out in your trans journey, comment below in the pinned post and I'll add here to pass it on
view the rest of the comments
I'm not really sure why anyone expects to love being trans - even if it weren't highly stigmatizing, it's also just not a good time. I don't like having to depend on exogenous hormones (let alone ones I have to inject with scary needles), and not having the right body or anatomy has been so acutely distressing at times I wasn't sure I was going to make it.
I think there is a reason a lot of us disappear into deep stealth once we can and don't build and maintain an identity as a visible trans person if there is an alternative, it's not only that trans people are mistreated in society, but being "trans" starts to feel like a deeper invalidation of who we are, and if we become cis-passing, an invalidation of who we have become. Why would we want to identify with the very label society uses to remind us of the invalidity of our gender? "Trans" really starts to feel like an asterisks, "trans woman" might as well be "woman*" (*the FDA has not reviewed this statement for accuracy).
I'm well aware that even if I tell queer allies that I'm trans, that what they hear is that I'm actually male, that my womanhood is fake. I just don't feel that's accurate, so I don't tell people I'm trans. I don't identify as trans. I don't want to be trans, and I don't have any interest in identifying as trans.
That said, I think the only reason we're having this conversation is because there has been a pride movement that has been trying to elevate trans folks - both in terms of visibility, but also our rights. There are brave men and women who own being trans and who have helped influence society towards better acceptance, and also so that other trans people can see an alternative to the social stigma and shame associated with being trans. (This is more than just visibility, even cultivating and propagating the idea that you could be proud of being trans, or the work done to help de-stigmatize gender dysphoria by recognizing that it's not all pathology, that we are a part of natural variation in humans.)
In this way I think you find some folks like Ada (and others I know IRL) who come (usually years into transition) to not only make peace with their trans identity, but who feel proud of it.
(At this point it seems there is even a "subversivism" that has emerged, where within some queer communities the dominant sexual and gender hierarchy is simply flipped, and being straight and cis are seen as negative while being queer in sexuality and gender are seen as preferred; but I'm not sure this is "pride", which in general I think is more reasonable and healthy.)
I can't really speak to what that pride is like, it might vary from person to person. I suspect it could be like a self esteem for the struggles you have endured and overcome to get where you are, and recognizing the way that has shaped you in ways you wouldn't trade.
Either way, I think the take-away is whether you integrate into cis-normative society and hide, or you become more secure in your identity and come to own it publicly, I suspect the further you get into your transition the better it gets. Surgeries, HRT, and experience with how to socially navigate the world as your gender should all improve and reduce gender dysphoria, and hopefully eventually you'll wake up one day and feel happy about who you are.
I think sometimes it's more comfortable being around queer folks because they're at least substantially less likely to say some wild shit and get offended if you so much as blink. With cishet people it takes a while to know that they're not secretly harboring some anti-queer bigotry to spring on you when you're not expecting it. I've definitely met cishets who "tolerate" trans people but actually look down on us and will flip the moment we do anything at all to defend our rights or suggest that we should have rights in the first place. Usually it's "apolitical" people who are actually just lazily conservative, but you never really know until it happens.
With queer people that's unusual enough for it to be notable.
That makes sense, esp. for folks early in transition or who struggle to be seen as their gender. Queer spaces might be the only places that you are seen as you, let alone where you are tolerated and not glared at.
At some point though I started to pass and especially cishet people cluelessly just see me as another straight, cis woman - and while I'm not technically either of those, I am a woman and it is more affirming to me to be seen as a cis woman than as a trans woman. In that context I've started to have a harder time being around queer folks because they're the only ones who notice I'm trans, and it outs me and I get treated differently and I feel degendered and dehumanized by it - instead of being a cis woman I suddenly become a trans woman (a woman*).
I keep flip flopping between wishing I was born a cis woman and being happy I'm trans. I think partly I do really want to look like a cis woman in all the subtle ways people take for granted, but also I know that if I was born a cis woman it wouldn't really be me at all. There are things about being trans women that are unique to us, and while society treats those things as bad and wrong and tries to punish us for being trans, or push us to transition more completely or not at all, I don't want to lose the parts of me that are unique and special just to pass better. Partly I feel that way because I have the body I have and accepting it for what it is even as I try to change it hurts less than the alternative, but also I want to love myself for who I am not become someone other people deem worthy of love.
The concept of intersectionality comes to mind. I'm trans, bi, have audhd, and probably aro. I've spent the majority of my life under complex layers of masks, hiding my neurodivergence, hiding my sexuality, hiding gender, hiding my lack of interest in traditional romantic relationships, trying to fit into boxes other people presented to me. I did that to myself every day for my entire life. I fabricated a person who never existed for the benefit of others and wounded myself emotionally, constantly, to keep up the facade. What I learned from that experience is that hiding myself doesn't really get me anything, because any love or affection or approval or praise that I got because of my masks meant nothing to me. If I could pass as neurotipical, straight, a man, whatever, and feel nothing for the accomplishments of that person I was playing, why would I feel any different about playing a cis woman? I'm not a cis woman. I have a penis and testicles. I have a y chromosome (as far as I know). I am who and what I am, and I want to love myself for the real me. I want my loved ones to love me for the real me. I want everyone to see the real me, see what the real me has accomplished. If they hate me for it at least they're hating the real me. That's better than them accepting a mask in my place. Idk. That's just how I feel about it.
Hmmmm, see I think we have different experiences - I feel living as a straight man was a real lie, whereas living as a cis woman feels entirely natural and compatible with who I am.
I do sort of feel what you're describing about how my trans-ness contributes to parts of who I am, but I think I would be more me if I were a cis woman (if that makes sense). I also just assume that because I'm bisexual and mostly sapphic that as a cis woman I would still be me in those authentic queer ways, and I think I sometimes can positively view my transness as connecting with my sexuality as a queer woman (like, maybe I look more like a lesbian as a trans woman?) ... but if I were cis I still think I would probably look like a lesbian and I wouldn't have lost anything crucial to what is me.
I think I also experience this alienation with my neurodivergence (assuming I'm right about being neurodivergent) - there are neurodivergent traits I have that very much make me "me", but which I do not endorse or like and wish were not how I am. (This makes it like the transness, it's definitely a big part of who I am, but I still have a strong desire to be different than this - it feels wrong, not like an authentic part of me, like a part of me I don't like or endorse.)
I think sometimes this topic comes up in disability discussions, about how some people can really identify with their condition (like neurodivergence), while others don't identify with them and experience it more as a pathology.
For me, my transness and my neurodivergence are more pathologies that are barriers in the way of being "me". I know not everyone experiences them this way, but it is how I experience them - and I think it's not uncommon that others experience it that way too.
When my partner loves my trans body or my body before transition, it doesn't make me feel loved - it feels like she loves someone else, because I didn't identify with my male or "hermaphroditic" body (for lack of a better term). What she sees is not the authentic or real me, and just because it's my body doesn't make it more authentic or real.
Maybe you just have a gender identity more compatible with your genderqueerness?