This is an ancient meme, well over 10 years old, perhaps born on Facebook? I've been looking up these older memes, to learn their secrets and thus to become a better memecrafter.
Can you identify them all? On Bluesky the alt text identified them as...
Alternative responses to "I Love You" from top left to bottom right: Robert Smith "Thanks.", Nik Fiend "Yeet", Andrew Eldrtich "Why.", Siouxsie Sioux "Who Doesn't", Nick Cave "I'm sorry.", Ian Curtis "A horrible decision, really", Carl McCoy finger guns, Peter Murphy "I know."
I knew 1, 3, 4, 5 & 6... because I was an 80's kid who listened to their music and still do some of the time... even when I became a teen in the 90's