this post was submitted on 01 Oct 2025
89 points (97.8% liked)

Space

1934 readers
89 users here now

A community to discuss space & astronomy through a STEM lens

Rules

  1. Be respectful and inclusive. This means no harassment, hate speech, or trolling.
  2. Engage in constructive discussions by discussing in good faith.
  3. Foster a continuous learning environment.

Also keep in mind, mander.xyz's rules on politics

Please keep politics to a minimum. When science is the focus, intersection with politics may be tolerated as long as the discussion is constructive and science remains the focus. As a general rule, political content posted directly to the instance’s local communities is discouraged and may be removed. You can of course engage in political discussions in non-local communities.


Related Communities

🔭 Science

🚀 Engineering

🌌 Art and Photography


Other Cool Links


founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS
 

...Earlier this century, some very strong evidence arrived showing that there was a Universe before the Big Bang, demonstrating that the Big Bang wasn’t truly the start of it all...

...The differences between a Universe that began with a hot Big Bang and a Universe that had an inflationary phase that precedes and sets up the hot Big Bang are subtle, but tremendously important...

...in a Universe that underwent a period of inflation prior to the start of the hot Big Bang, we’d expect there to be density fluctuations on all scales, including on scales larger than the speed of light, which could have allowed a signal to travel since the start of the hot Big Bang...

Although later fluctuations superimpose themselves atop the older, earlier, larger-scale fluctuations, inflation allows us to start the Universe off with ultra-large-scale fluctuations that shouldn’t exist in the Universe if it began with a Big Bang singularity without inflation.

...At any moment in the Universe’s history, there’s a limit to how far a signal that’s been traveling at the speed of light since the start of the hot Big Bang could’ve traveled, and that scale sets what’s known as the cosmic horizon...scales that are greater than the horizon, known as super-horizon scales, are beyond the limit of what could’ve been caused by physical signals generated at or since the start of the hot Big Bang.

...When we look at the final (2018-era) Planck TE cross-correlation data, below, the results are breathtaking...As you can clearly see, there can be no doubt that there truly are super-horizon fluctuations within the Universe, as the significance of this signal is overwhelming. The fact that we see super-horizon fluctuations, and that we see them not merely from reionization but as they are predicted to exist from inflation, is a slam dunk: the non-inflationary, singular Big Bang model does not match up with the Universe we observe.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments

Only going to touch on the article since I am not a physicist and yet: I suspect the article is bunk, because it seems to be trying to separate the big bang and inflation theory into competing theories.

General layman understanding of things in a nutshell. this may be completely wrong, and is likely full of "Lies-To-Children"

  1. Everything compressed into singularity.
  2. Big bang, everything is super hot plasma.
  3. Faster than light expansion of the universe. Too hot to make anything out with the tools we have.
  4. Things cool and the inflation stops being completely insane, the base fluctuations remaining from the big bang result in inequal distribution of matter, the first supermassive stars and their accretion discs form.
  5. Those stars die and form into the supermassive black holes that form the seeds of all galaxies.
  6. Because of whatever Dark Energy is, something related to a lack matter in space, the space between clusters of galaxies and clusters of clusters of galaxies, the rate of inflation of universe starts increasing and things start moving apart.