this post was submitted on 27 Aug 2024
226 points (98.3% liked)
RetroGaming
29390 readers
207 users here now
Vintage gaming community.
Rules:
- Be kind.
- No spam, AI slop, or soliciting for money.
- No racism or other bigotry allowed.
- Obviously nothing illegal.
If you see these please report them.
founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Let's spread the news far and wide so Nintendo takes it down.
It's a set of patches for the base ISO, so hopefully it's pretty resistant to takedown? In either case I'm downloading it now while it's up.
It's a patch that requires a "legitimately" acquired ROM to work. This is how sites like SMW World avoid C&D's, they host patches and mods and don't have the actual ROMs on site. Nintendo can't take it down because none of their code is there.
Didn't stop them for C&D plenty of mods for BOTW and TOTK.
Wasn't that more about cracking the encryption on those games and leaking them early rather than modding them?
No? There's no leaking happening over at gamebanana, why are you confusing it with the Yuzu situation?
Downloaded it right away anyway before it gets taken down lol since you never know
At least it's already available for download.
Yup, this is where these projects usually fail. The creators get too excited not to share the work in progress and it gets killed before a proper release. A release is available forever.
I've been hearing about this one for a few years already, I think if there were grounds to take it down it would have happened already
As we know, once something is released on the internet, it is super easy to remove.
Especially if it has widespread knowledge and downloads.
These things being taken down is an eventuality no one can avoid, however if no one but Nintendo sees it, and takes it down, not many people will know about it.
By spreading these things when they are good it encourages a lot of things. It encourages backups, communities dedicated to preservation of files or at least discussion of them (through piracy of course, though still counts). Making more people aware of them also makes some talented individuals realise that they have the capability to get into these things themselves. Etc.
I for one had no idea about this prior to this post, and Super Mario: Sunshine is one of my favourite games, so I'm excited to try this mod out later.
Real
Nintendo really only has a history of taking down fan remakes of existing Nintendo games or games that are charging money. They've never to my knowledge had a free fan game or romhack taken down nor do I think they'd have any sort of legal grounds to do so even if they wanted to. And this essentially boils down to a ROM hack. Which is almost certainly completely safe from Nintendo's lawyers since it doesn't contain any Nintendo made assets.