this post was submitted on 17 Feb 2025
29 points (96.8% liked)

Doctor Who

2618 readers
11 users here now

A good old fashioned Doctor Who Community

founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
 

Hey, I’m a huge Star Trek fan and have seen all of that stuff endlessly.

I love the Star Trek community, and it seems Doctor who has a similar thing.

So, I want to check out this show. Can someone recommend a good place to start?

Can I just pick a series based on the actor? I was considering the series with Matt Smith. Just because I saw a few clips with him.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] [email protected] 17 points 1 month ago* (last edited 1 month ago) (1 children)

Can I just pick a series based on the actor?

Yeah. That's the deal with Doctor Who. Some episodes from the earliest actors to play The Doctor are lost anyway.

The first episode with each new actor is meant to be a starting point for new fans.

Matt Smith's Doctor is a great choice.

Be aware though, that much like different series of Star Trek have different vibes, different seasons of Doctor Who do, as well.

Matt Smith's Doctor Who is as often borderline fairytale fantasy as science fiction. (Though with enough extreme patience, and a little bit of generosity, one could argue that most unexplained bits get plausibly explained later.)

  • Eccleston'a era is more distopian.
  • Tennant's era has more retro futuristic adventure.
  • Smith: Fairy tales in space and time
  • Capaldi's era is rock and roll scifi.
  • Whitaker's era returns to the shows roots of exploring history.
  • Gatwa: Fairy tales, again, but sexier

And, because I'm old:

  • Peter Cushing (yes. That one.): Scifi Horror
  • Hartnell: Exploring history.
  • Troughton: Morality Tales in Space and Time.
  • Pertwee: Scifi Horror
  • Tom Baker: Shakespeare in Space and Time
  • Atkinson: Dark Comedy in Space and Time
  • Davidson: Hardy Boys Mysteries in Space and Time
  • Colin Baker: Rock Opera in Space and Time
  • McCoy: The Twilight Zone
  • McGann: Shakespeare in Space and Time, revisited, with a touch of rock opera.

Have fun!

[–] [email protected] 2 points 1 month ago (1 children)

Thanks for the write-up. I am really happy to see the breakdown of genre by doctor. I might actually like Eccleston's the most. Luckily, I decided to just start with him as I also like tennant as an actor. I'm just 2.5 episodes in so far, but I am enjoying it and looking forward to watching more episodes tonight.

[–] [email protected] 3 points 1 month ago

Yeah I think Eccleston is the best place to start personally, that's the beginning of the revival and they kind of 'reset' a lot of stuff and gradually reintroduce the key ideas of the show from there.

It's a bit cheese in places and some parts haven't aged well at all (some of it looked shit even in 2005 lol) but also that's just part of the show. It's a bonkers mess that sometimes doesn't work at all and sometimes is the best thing ever.