The Players Voice award always goes to some gacha trash, cause they incentivise their players to go vote. "If we win, we'll give everyone free shit".
Sad to see that so many FANTASTIC games ended up with nil, because E33 stole the show so hard, but it's tough to argue that they didn't deserve each one. Myself, I probably would've put Silksong over E33 for art direction, it's ASTOUNDING to me how much of a step up the artwork in that game was, compared to Hollow Knight.
I do wish that they would adjust their criteria for "indie" game. E33 really shouldn't have been counted as one, IMO. Hundreds of people worked on that game, as many as some AAA games, and yet games like Blue Prince, from a solo developer (or very close to it?) had to compete against that? That really defies the spirit of the indie category, for me. Even if we count JUST the core team of (supposedly) 33, that puts it squarely in AA territory, for me.
Which list? It WAS a nominee for Best Indie.