If you're going to be a rebel, either do it secretly (sabotage) or in large numbers. Don't throw away your life for nothing.
Microblog Memes
A place to share screenshots of Microblog posts, whether from Mastodon, tumblr, ~~Twitter~~ X, KBin, Threads or elsewhere.
Created as an evolution of White People Twitter and other tweet-capture subreddits.
RULES:
- Your post must be a screen capture of a microblog-type post that includes the UI of the site it came from, preferably also including the avatar and username of the original poster. Including relevant comments made to the original post is encouraged.
- Your post, included comments, or your title/comment should include some kind of commentary or remark on the subject of the screen capture. Your title must include at least one word relevant to your post.
- You are encouraged to provide a link back to the source of your screen capture in the body of your post.
- Current politics and news are allowed, but discouraged. There MUST be some kind of human commentary/reaction included (either by the original poster or you). Just news articles or headlines will be deleted.
- Doctored posts/images and AI are allowed, but discouraged. You MUST indicate this in your post (even if you didn't originally know). If an image is found to be fabricated or edited in any way and it is not properly labeled, it will be deleted.
- Absolutely no NSFL content.
- Be nice. Don't take anything personally. Take political debates to the appropriate communities. Take personal disagreements & arguments to private messages.
- No advertising, brand promotion, or guerrilla marketing.
RELATED COMMUNITIES:
Inb4 someone mentions Chenoweth's research which conclusively shows that "non-violent" [1] protest is more effective.
[1] here non-violence is defined to include but not be limited to the use of molotov cocktails, plowing through the crowd in a speeding car, burning down government buildings, and assasination attempts. Somehow the headlines always fail to mention this little bit of nuance. Super weird.
It's very simple, really.
We want government because it helps manage infrastructure, distribute wealth (sometimes), provide social services, offer protection and peace, and for all these benefits, we grumpily get to accept state monopoly on violence
They want government because it's violent, and for that they grumpily get to accept building infrastructure, providing social services, distributing wealth, offering protection and peace. They really, really want for the government to only be violent and do nothing else.
The boundaries of a state are pretty much defined by the monopoly on violence. If someone else is able to use violence whenever they want within a certain territory, they can make their own laws and enforce those laws with the threat of violence. If it's unclear whose laws apply, then you don't really have a state.
The good things a state can do are more or less defined by its laws. Protection from theft or murder requires laws. Progressive taxation is a law. Even a fire department that comes and puts out house fires exists and is supported by a series of laws. For those laws to be in effect, someone has to have the authority to deal with people who break the laws, which requires that they have a monopoly on violence.
An important thing to remember is that a monopoly on violence doesn't mean that the state automatically does use violence. Most modern states function with a bare minimum of violence. What it does require is that nobody other than the state gets to use violence.
You really did steal this lmao. But yeah this does hit it on the head.
I'm a man of my word lol
'Violence is not the way', says the cabal of ultra rich, genocidal sociopaths.
You don't need to be violent to eat the rich. Use local numbing agents.
when words and legislation fail, it is the only way left to us
When you make peaceful revolution impossible, you make violent revolution inevitable.
Isn't that what defines a state? Having a monopoly on violence and being able to secure its borders?
In some sense, yes. The secure the borders thing a weird and unnecessary addition, but the monopoly on violence thing is pretty spot on. The state has a legal monopoly on violence. But that position is not at all what the OP is arguing against.
Some people would extend the above to a kind of moral monopoly. They see someone employ violent tactics to rebel against the state, and they will say "this is morally wrong", or "this is not the way to do things", or "would someone please think of the optics?". They look at the violence employed by people in the BLM movement and argue against it. They look at the stonewall riots and argue against it. They look at people violently resisting the nazis in the second world war, and they argue against it, from a moral perpective. That is what this post is about.
Except in an oligarchy violence is also coming from the wealthy.
Yes, but you don't get the internet points with that kind of nuanced argument.
It's so weird how my public education really stressed that non-violence was the best way to get things done but only gave two extremely cherry-picked examples versus the entirety of human history. Super duper weird.
Ghisline Maxwell’s dad published our textbooks
Violence was the only thing that stopped me from being bullied my entire childhood. Teachers didn't care. Other parents didn't care. Principals didn't care. Just the same old "Just ignore them and they'll go away". Okay, I'll just ignore them putting their hands around my throat and choking me, I'll get right the fuck on that.
The first time I ever defended myself physically while being literally strangled during gym class, I cold cocked the guy in the temple enough to drop him to the ground and let go. I got suspended. The person literally trying to do irreparable harm to me got no punishment at all. Right in the middle of a football field in gym class in front of 20 other students and two teachers.
I got suspended for "fighting back".

They also tended to avoid teaching too much about people like Malcolm X or Fred Hampton. Had to learn about them on my own.
Its seems all the peaceful movements had a violent counterpart going on at the same time, which made the peaceful version appealing to the ruling class.
Though both Malcolm X and MLK were assassinated because ultimately they didn't want either.
I feel like you might be mixing two things here.
If there is a non-violent solution to a problem, that should always be preferred and is also IMO the best way in the grand scheme of things. And if there is not, it might be also worth considering if the problem to be solved is actually a problem in the first place. But a few problems are left where violence might be the only solution.
Also “the best” doesn’t mean “the most effective”. Many many problems can be solved pretty effectively with a violent act. Or the violence is the simplest approach. But it wouldn’t be the best.
Big if
Without defining what "the best" and "most effective" mean for you, your entire comment is a bit of a non sequitur.
"effective" is a binary measure; pretty much absolute. "best" typically implies "optimum" or "efficient", so a trade-off, because a one-sided effect is typically not optimal. And as I said: sometimes the effective solutions is the optimal one. But I think that's the exception.
Yes, but within this context what is the threshold for effective? What is the metric by which you measure efficiency?
arguably state violence is worse than other violence because everyone chipped in for it.
We should be hunting ICE agents for sport. The fact that not one, masked, armed, kidnapper has not had a single bullet fly in his direction is a complete failure of the citizenry.
And before someone says something smart ass, they're nowhere near me. I actively look.
I wouldn't trust either of those sites, they're not showing any of the ICE activity near me at all. Are you involved in your local rapid response groups?
Well if its going to be a sport, then there needs to be a league. And after the past couple years of league sports Iʻm deeply not OK with sports teams being allowed to move geographies. So whatever league ends up forming up needs to have rules about franchises moving cities.
I donʻt want to find out the Honolulu ICE Hammmahʻs are moving to Detroit some day.
Oh, it happened. They just weren't shot BECAUSE they were ICE. They got shot and happened to be ICE.
@shalafi@lemmy.world There was also this one instance LINK HERE where a sniper shot at the ICE but only manage to hit the detainees killing Miguel Angel Garcia-Hernandez, 31, and Norlan Guzman-Fuentes, 37.
Be peaceful, not helpless
Like the Starship Enterprise! Peaceful, diverse, accepting, curious, loving... and armed to the FUCKING teeth in case some motherfucker has just got to find out.
I'm not gonna go out looking for a fight, mind. But if I see one happen, I know whose side I'm on, because no, I didn't get a good look at his face. That's all.