cross-posted from: https://mander.xyz/post/45570248
...
China wanted to outbuild Europe and the United States by launching the Circular Electron Positron Collider (CEPC), a colossal ring that would dwarf CERN’s famous Large Hadron Collider under the fields near Geneva. The idea was simple to state and insanely hard to realize: construct the biggest, cleanest “Higgs factory” on Earth, then follow it with a proton-proton collider that would push deeper into the unknown. Physicists around the world quietly redid their career plans around that dream.
Then came the bill. As cost estimates climbed into the multi‑billion, then tens‑of‑billions range, the tone in official Chinese statements cooled. Internal debates surfaced about whether a giant collider delivered enough value compared to quantum computing, AI, fusion, or simply shoring up the economy. The CEPC, once floated as a flagship national prestige project, slipped into a diplomatic grey zone. No cancellation speech, no ribbon‑cutting either — just delay, silence, recalibration. For a project built on speed and ambition, this slow fade spoke louder than any press conference.
...
Scientists in China like to tell the story of how the original CEPC concept emerged from small, late‑night workshops in 2012 and 2013. Back then, the Higgs boson had just been confirmed at CERN, and the feeling worldwide was that the next step should be bolder, cleaner, bigger. In those early talks, the question wasn’t if China could lead, but how fast.
...
That dream met a harsher reality after 2015, when Chinese growth slowed and the global mood turned more anxious. Giant infrastructure projects used to be easy political wins; you poured concrete, took photos, claimed progress. A collider is different. You bury billions in the ground and wait years for results the public can’t touch or hold. As budgets tightened and geopolitical tensions escalated, the collider’s price tag started to look less like a badge of leadership and more like a risky bet.
...
There was never a single dramatic moment where a Chinese official walked to a podium and killed the CEPC on live television. Instead, the project drifted into the limbo where grand plans quietly go to sleep. Public roadmaps became vaguer. Key milestones slid into “future phases.” Teams that had spent a decade sharpening designs found themselves repackaging those same plans as “long-term options.” It’s the modern way of cancelling something without admitting defeat. You don’t say “never”. You say “not now”. And you let the silence do the work.
...
At the heart of the decision is a brutally simple trade‑off: the cost per additional unit of knowledge. Pushing beyond the energies of the LHC doesn’t just require a slightly bigger ring. It demands new magnets, new materials, new cooling systems, and a small army of highly specialized engineers.
...
When you’re a global superpower juggling aging populations, regional inequality, and a turbulent tech war, a multi‑decade moonshot suddenly looks like a luxury.
...
There’s another layer, more subtle and just as real: prestige fatigue. For two decades, China has stacked up megaprojects — record‑breaking bridges, high‑speed rail, massive dams, space stations. A collider is different precisely because its victory is invisible to most citizens. No one rides a particle beam to work. And while discovering a new particle might one day change everything, it’s hard to sell that promise on a TV news segment between housing prices and local weather.
...