this post was submitted on 08 Jan 2026
17 points (94.7% liked)
PC Gaming
8442 readers
42 users here now
Rule #1: Be civil
Rule #2: No spam, memes, off-topic, or low-effort posts/comments
Rule #3: No advertisements
Rule #4: No streams, random gameplay videos, highlights, or shorts
Rule #5: No erotic games or porn
Rule #6: No facilitating piracy
Rule #7: No duplicates
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
I was disappointed to find that Red Dead Redemption 2 is just a linear series of cutscenes without any real player agency - more graphic novel than game. I thought it was going to be Skyrim with guns when I bought it. Its the last game I'll buy without demoing/pirating first.
RDR2 is a game at odds with itself.
A supreme open world, combined with a story mode so linear that you can fail missions by taking a few steps in the wrong direction.
This is shocking to me. I found it to be the best open world game ever made. One of the few I ever went back and played again.
You could hunt, fish, explore, etc. for 100+ hours without finishing the story. Ask me how I know.
This being one of the games that turned me off AAA single player narrative action adventure games. They're pretty much TV shows but not as good as TV shows yet take way longer than TV shows to develop so why play these games
Are you sure you got the right game? I got over 170 hours of fun out of it. My niece plays it exclusively as a horse simulator.
It does have too many lengthy linear sections (in my opinion) but once you're allowed to free roam it's possibly one of the best open worlds ever made.