60
Guybrush Threepwood won good person loved by fans. Which adventure game character is morally gray and loved by fans?
(retrolemmy.com)
It took some time to break the tie, but Guybrush won eventually!
Luffy in One Piece also wants to be a pirate, but seems to have no idea what pirates actually do. In Monkey Island, the worst thing a pirate might do is insult you. They fight with wit; the swords are just for aesthetics.
If you haven't played them, I highly recommend it. At least the originals. It's like playing a 90s cartoon. Like all the Lucasarts classics.