Microblog Memes

I think I was too abstract about it to properly make sense.

So: People have started using "political" to mean for example some movie star saying that Israel shouldn't be killing all those people, or NFL players kneeling, or movies having queer people in them sometimes. Those are the "other things" that I was saying that are being defined as "political." When "political" is used to criticize this stuff, it basically means that they are demanding that no other people in the world have opinions about it or speak out about them, unless they're agreeing with the baseline that is defined as "not political." The genders for video game character are "male" and "political," the races for a sitcom character are "white" and "political," the politics for a football player are "Republican" and "political." And so on.

It is true that those same people never define it as "political" when someone is having opinions (usually much more explicitly and tribally political) that agree with their own. It's only "political" when it's against their opinions, and even if the "political" content is in some totally apolitical way, which is why they're all of a sudden freaking out about Star Wars and Sesame Street. That was sort of what I was alluding to, I guess a little unclearly, in the first part.

But I'm not even talking about that too much. I'm saying that in addition to being aware of that discrepancy, we shouldn't even be buying into that redefinition of the word. If Star Wars had someone come out and say that you should make sure to vote for the Democrats because they have more sensible fiscal policy, that would be political. If Tim Tebow put a big Obama sticker on his helmet, that would be political. Both of those would actually be fine (and happen all the time in the other direction, and pretty rarely in the anti-Republican direction), but in any case, the expansion of "political" to mean that any type of worldview which happens to make some politicians look bad or disagree with them is automatically "political" is what I was objecting to, in this case applied to Star Wars. It's just a story about good guys and bad guys. You don't have to be political to dislike Nixon or use him as a template internally for an evil character or something. It's just good sense, Nixon was a piece of shit. He was a bad guy. If you dislike him because he's a Republican, that's political.