this post was submitted on 09 Dec 2024
877 points (98.3% liked)
interestingasfuck
8615 readers
1 users here now
For exceptionally interesting content
Rules:
- Posts must be interesting
- Posts must be based in reality
- No hateful content
- No harmful content
- Beauty is in the eye of the beholder
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Quote is crazy hard but I disagree with you so much lol
You can't act like the Civil War didn't happen. We put men on the moon. We developed the Atomic bomb. We have 11 aircraft carriers. Whether it fits your argument or not Americans have grit and we will take back our power.
I find it interesting that nothing you listed is contemporary. Even the aircraft carriers. We've have a lot of aircraft carriers for a long time.
You're reaching pretty far back to find anything of significance Americans have done that's positive. And some of what you listed is decidedly not positive.
Maybe you're thinking about what Americans USED to be.
And you are just as easily invalidating things they've done because it fits your narrative.
There are a lot of points in history I'd bring up to show the grit of Americans before those specific ones. The Civil War was fought to keep the wealth-generating plantations under the federal tax jurisdiction, the moon landing was a cool thing that happened 50 years ago and produced no real tangible benefits at a point of time where those resources could've been put to much better use, the A-bomb was a war crime and our aircraft carriers are used to support illegal wars to kill brown people protect the interests of oil companies.
You are saying that these things are bad things. I'm not saying they aren't. I'm saying Americans achieve things. Americans are fucking tough. Also, I will argue that you couldn't pop a pimple of truth on this statement: "he moon landing was a cool thing that happened 50 years ago and produced no real tangible benefits".
Oh, by golly, are you wrong.
These lists are completely disingenuous. Just because something was the first use case doesn't mean it was the only use case for a thing.
For example. Freeze dried food. It's completely impossible to say we would not have freeze dried food without the space program.
You're doing the country equivalent "I'm not pathetic, look at how big my muscles are". Doesn't matter if you have shitty public education, shitty public transportation, shitty worker rights, shitty health care and a shitty political system that makes change impossible, you can beat the shit out of anyone calling you pathetic.
Such a simplistic view I can absolutely believe you're American.
"I don't like the things republicans do, so all of America are shitty wimps."
-You.
Assuming all of those things are inflicted by republicans, how can they get away with it? You're supposed to have grit and take back power, but somehow you're letting republicans run wild? How doesn't this rub of on all Americans?
No, fucker, WE didn't do any of that. WE are shitposting on Lemmy. I know for a fact you didn't build any aircraft carriers yourself. So can "WE" stop talking credit for things less pathetic Americans have done?
Ugh.....Yeah.....we did. My fucking neighbor welds submarines. I work in manufacturing assisting in building cars, tanks, radar systems, military vehicles. You name it. You might be some tech nerd like most people on Lemmy, but most of us out here in the real world are doing hard shit.
Pretty bold of you to claim us nerds don't do hard shit. I'm only going to speak to my experience, but I'm only one small slice of the nerd demographic. My background is in network design, security, availability, and global network design. I started out life in a car parts factory, graduated to being on the line crew here, before going inside to work on computers.
How much of your logistics would crumble without us? Exchange of knowledge around the globe? Sales and interfacing with other corporations and customers? Security to keep personal information somewhat protected?
I've contracted with several fortune 100 companies in all sorts of different industries all over the world, from manufacturing to attorneys.
You sound a lot like my family. Only hard labour is virtuous, if you aren't sweating you aren't working. Do you look down on people who do what you consider menial labour? I doubt you'll admit it, but I'm pretty confident you do.
Civilization doesn't work if we think like you. Every single person in my life, from the guys picking up my trash to the surgeon that saved my life are important and necessary to making modern life what it is.
Trying to be divisive between blue and white collar in the working glass is definitely a suspicious fucking take in this climate.
So you agree then? America is not a bunch of pathetic people who are going to bend over to fascism?
I didn't speak to that at all. Intentionally.
What I think about what people will or won't do has nothing to do with your divisive thinking.
A.) I don't believe you. B.) I don't care.
Top quality comment. Do you feel good about yourself for commenting that?
The atomic bombs and iarcraft carriers are for "Americans (people)"