I (24M) am kind of wondering if there's a class of people out there who were effectively immune to patriarchal conditioning because they had loving, secure parents who told them that it was all bullshit and they went on to become loving, secure adults.
I fell for it because I had abusive parents who made me feel that my needs were a burden, and society's "man up" attitude and contempt for male vulnerability reinforced that message. I was unable to trust anyone or find women attractive because I saw everyone as a threat and believed that they would all be hostile towards me if I revealed my emotional needs. Every instance where I saw men presented as the "strong" gender reinforced my fears.
I could not feel safe around others until I knew that men and women didn't have fundamentally different ways of thinking and feeling, and to do that, I had to slowly dismantle every "fact" I learned about the "male brain" versus the "female brain" and the gender binary. I also had to learn about and accept my emotional needs, including the loving and emotionally vulnerable sex I wanted that looked nothing like mainstream porn.
Only now, after more than a decade of gradually shedding my Christofascist indoctrination and becoming a radical socialist, do I finally feel safe enough to experience attraction and the desire for romance. I just turned 24, and I started deprogramming at 13.
So, was there just a large contingent of people who never fell for any of this garbage? The male brain vs female brain essentialist nonsense, sex-negative purity culture, the gender binary, the lack of emotional intimacy in porn, and the patriarchal trash everywhere? How can so many people love and respect each other and be normal with all these ideas floating around in society, unless some people were highly resistant to them?
I feel like there are a lot of progressive people on Lemmy who are secure in themselves and always had it right. And they can just find love and make friends in a healthy way, blissfully ignorant of all of the people and ideas that belong on c/AreTheStraightsOK.
What are your experiences?
First of all, "immune" is quite a strong word. I prefer the word "resistant to" patriarchal conditioning.
I was recently diagnosed with autism, which may be a factor. Studies have shown that autistic people are more resistant to advertising. It's the kind of thing where I was always AWARE of advertising and I'm not arrogant enough to assume that none of it works on me, but I am always shocked at how everyone around me seems so easily influenced by social forces and the quest for social status.
I grew up in a lower-middle class family. My father had bi-polar and schizophrenia amongst other issues, which led to my parents getting divorced when I was young. My father loved me and wanted a relationship with my sisters and me, but eventually all 3 of us separately went no-contact with him. His whole family (his parents, 6 sisters, and their dozens of children) all pretty much abandoned my mother and her 3 children. So at 7 years old I was "the man of the house", surrounded by my mother and sisters.
My maternal grandfather was not a particularly masculine man. He was short and slight of build, probably from growing up malnourished during the Great Depression. A thinker, not a fighter. My mother's sister had a husband, and they had two daughters, but my uncle was not a huge presence in my life.
So I spent a lot of my formative years, including going through puberty, surrounded by mostly women. We were poor and I was an introverted nerd, so I spent a lot of time reading my older sister's young-adult fantasy novels about teenaged girls becoming strong independent women, challenging gender norms. I watched my mother and older sister work on the car, take out the trash, lift heavy objects, etc. They survived perfectly fine without a male presence. My older sister is also autistic and is, by far, the most intelligent person I have ever met in my life. So when I heard other boys say "girls are stupid", my reaction was to think the person saying that was clearly wrong.
I still remember my father making casual sexist jokes. Some of it mean-spirited misogyny, some of it the chauvinism of benevolent sexism. I'm glad that I avoided a lot of that. My step-dad would later come into the picture and do some of that too, but I was no longer impressionable at that point.
At school, I was not a competitive person. I did not do very well in sports. My friends were the boys who were the other nerdy outcasts, most of whom have come out as gay or trans in adulthood. I also made friends with the nerdy girls. I gave them space, treated them as equals, respected them, did not try to talk over anyone. I listened to the girls at school and my sisters at home complain about other boys, and I took those lessons to heart about how not to act towards women.
I was not perfect. With my first girlfriend, I ended up filling the classic role of the "white knight" chauvinist. I paid for everything, treated her like a princess, tried to protect her from the world. That was also around the time when I became aware of the prevalence of sexual abuse around me. My girlfriend had spent her ages 7-16 being regularly raped by her stepfather, and a lot of our relationship was her trying to come to terms with that trauma. Her best friend revealed she had spent years being raped by a family friend. All of the girls I had been friends with when I was younger suddenly seemed to both find the strength to talk about it and deem me safe enough to talk to about the men in their lives who hurt them. My response was to run... literally, but not figuratively. I had been overweight for my entire life, was a 17 year old filled with hormones, and was suddenly surrounded by stories of people I cared about being hurt by people who bore a resemblance to me. Running was a way to get healthier both physically and emotionally. In retrospect, I think part of my treatment of my girlfriend was feelings of guilt by association. I wanted to try to "make up" for what she experienced, to try to throw some positive male influence out into the world to offset some of the evil. My intentions were good, but the methods and results were bad. I was infantalizing her and participating in benevolent sexism. I was not trusting her to solve her own problems, and thus was not leaving her any space to grow as a person. I was feeling guilt for something I was absolutely not responsible for. I made it about me in a way, which was kind of selfish. We were both young and made a lot of mistakes in that relationship. We went to different colleges and eventually she dumped me for someone at her school. I took about a year to focus on myself, reflect on the relationship and my mistakes, and to think about who I wanted to be in the future.
I worked in retail in college, A lot of my colleagues were women who were taller than me. My boss was a woman shorter than me, but a former body builder in her college days. I also worked with women who were conventionally attractive and were clearly used to getting preferential treatment from straight men, and they were surprised it did not work on me. I worked with men who were assholes and men who were kind. Tall, short, gay, straight, mean, nice, man, woman, black, white. I saw every combination imaginable. Any time I started to see a pattern of behavior emerging, life seemed to purposely throw a counter-example in my face. Eventually I stopped paying attention to the patterns and just focused on the behaviors.
My best friend during this period was a Cantonese man I went to high school with. He grew up with an "asian tiger mom" (his words, not mine) and a father who was demure and meek and submitted to his mother. I think he also managed to avoid a lot of toxic masculinity, and that was probably why we were such good friends.
Another good friend of mine at that time was a lesbian. I used to hang out at the Subway where she worked and we would talk about women and dating together. Eventually we started dating, and we recently celebrated our 8 year wedding anniversary.
When we first started dating, my wife made more money than me. I still made enough for my share of the bills though, so I was fine with it. We were both poor. We split the chores evenly. Eventually she became disabled, with good days and bad days. Dropped out of school, bounced around various minimum-wage jobs. I finished my degree and got an office job. After a few years I was working 9-5 M-F in an office and making $60k, while she was struggling through chaotic schedules of evenings and weekends, exhausting her FMLA at each job, and never made $10k. So eventually she came to me and said what we both knew - it would make way more sense for her to stop working and just focus on doing household chores. It meant tightening our belts a little bit, but we would have much more time to spend together. We bought more clothes and she learned how to do meal prep, so she could take advantage of her good days and mitigate the impact of her bad days. I continued to advance in my career to the point where I now make nearly twice the HOUSEHOLD income of our local area, so we are comfortable.
We are both conscious of the stereotype we are accidentally enforcing - the husband as the sole breadwinner who is domestically incompetent, the domestic housewife who is financially dependent. I am very aware that our situation is specific to US, and that every relationship is different. I still try to take opportunities every now-and-then to do some of her chores just so I remember how. When we bought new laundry machines I made sure I knew how to use them. I have sick days and PTO at my job - she does not. So when she is sick, I step up and do more chores. I take a couple of weeks of staycation every year, and I use some of that time to take over chores and give her a bit of a break too. Part of her responsibilities include finding ways for us to save money too. She has gotten good at grocery shopping and thrifting. She keeps a mental map of gas prices at all of the stations in town.
Beyond that, I try to treat people equally everywhere. One of my closest colleague is a black woman. I see other people try to talk over her, or try to go around her and ask me to make decisions that are hers to make. I push back, make sure that she is heard, give her credit for her ideas. I do that for everyone I work with equally - there are some other white guys who are probably also autistic who are just really quiet and meek who also get talked over. There are women who talk over men. I do what I can to make sure everyone is heard and respected.
I've also avoided networks of misogynistic men. It could be that I'm autistic or introverted. I avoid large friend groups in general. I am not very socially motivated and quite happy spending a lot of time alone or just with my wife. But I pay attention to how other people treat not just me, but everyone else around them. So when I meet a guy and he starts making "wife bad" jokes, I immediately see that as a red flag and maintain some social distance. If I see a group of women picking on another woman for her looks, I also clock that as a red flag. I do not feel any obligation to put up with that nonsense in order to attain social status or power.