this post was submitted on 15 Nov 2026
660 points (98.5% liked)
tumblr
6622 readers
1 users here now
Welcome to /c/tumblr, a place for all your tumblr screenshots and news.
Our Rules:
-
Keep it civil. We're all people here. Be respectful to one another.
-
No sexism, racism, homophobia, transphobia or any other flavor of bigotry. I should not need to explain this one.
-
Must be tumblr related. This one is kind of a given.
-
Try not to repost anything posted within the past month. Beyond that, go for it. Not everyone is on every site all the time.
-
No unnecessary negativity. Just because you don't like a thing doesn't mean that you need to spend the entire comment section complaining about said thing. Just downvote and move on.
Sister Communities:
-
/c/TenForward@lemmy.world - Star Trek chat, memes and shitposts
-
/c/Memes@lemmy.world - General memes
founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
What is happening? I only found stuff about Buddhists being oppressed in the recent history.
https://thereader.mitpress.mit.edu/monks-behaving-badly-explaining-buddhist-violence-in-asia/
They're doing a genocide of Muslims.
Isn't generalizing the entirety of Buddhism based on the actions of one or two extremist factions, kind of exactly the same thing as generalizing the entirety of Islam based on the actions of one or two extremist factions?
Looking forward to seeing the mental gymnastics that it will take to claim those two things are in any way different
Not really.
True Believer fundamentalists depend on the moderates to exist.
I'm not an expert on Buddhism, but I know with Abrahamics the moderates finance and enable the fundies (often without knowing), and provide them with a veneer of respectability.
Fundies are by nature parasitic. You can see this with sects of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam, all depend on more "practical" donors for financing and support why they do more esoteric things.
If you're trying to fit eastern religions into a western-religion-shaped shoebox, you're going to have a very hard time defending your thesis to anyone who's even modestly informed on the topic.
They aren't? That's why we don't say all Muslims are the same as the Taliban or all Christians the same as MAGA.
Then what's the point of this post? Because it sounds like "Buddhism bad because there's at least one bad faction that can be identified in its entire history"
the point is that the most people believe buddhism as a whole has always been a-ok and that's simply false.
What is "buddhism as a whole" then? In your words, how would you describe that?
All religion are bad but some are worse if you go deep and learn real rules of each. Atheism should not exist as it should default in this modern world
You say that as someone who seems to have very little understanding of "real" buddhism, and you're making assumptions based on a biased opinion and preconceived notions about religion as a whole.
"if you go deep" anything can be bad, including atheism. If your goal is fault-finding, you'll always be successful.
If your goal is finding something that can be beneficial to people, society, or the world, you can find those things too.
If the good outweighs the bad, then getting rid of it would cause more harm than good.
And again I state that it's chauvinistic of you to decide for other people what they can or can't hold as religious beliefs and practices.
Enforced atheism is a form of thought-policing. When someone asks "what if there is more to life than this material world that meets the eye and is observable by specialized equipment," suddenly you need to go issuing fines for thought crime.
Banning religion is a treacherous and unhealthy thing to do for a society. Better to focus on the harms that particular sects and people cause, and punish those, and shape policy around preventing those harms. Not nuking the whole thing.
The post doesn’t say that Buddhism or Christianity are bad. Westerners are just more familiar with the fucked up parts of Christian history than the fucked up parts of Buddhist history. As a result Buddhism is sort of portrayed as this peaceful religion whose adherents do no wrong, which doesn’t survive contact with actually reading about history.
Interesting you say Westerners when my experience with the "Stop saying all religions are bad, Buddhists never did anything wrong" people are typically Asian.
Can they typically read Chinese history books? Because the person portrayed in the OP can’t. I think it’s pretty clearly implying someone from a different cultural background who is unfamiliar with Buddhist history, like most Westerners whose deepest thought about Buddhism is usually along the lines of ‘peaceful monk’.
People in the west who also know nothing about buddhism, also tend to do a lot of hand-waving and virtue signaling about western misconceptions of buddhism.
Do a lot of misconceptions about buddhism exist in the west? Yes, of course. Is every notion of buddhism entertained in the west a misconception? Not by a longshot. And unless you know which is which, it's kind of chauvinistic to go around declaring every statement made about buddhism to be "orientalist."
There are people in the west, both scholars and practitioners, who understand buddhism on a much deeper level than the average normie who only knows about a few miscontextualized concepts that were appropriated by the "self-help" industry. As well as on a much deeper level than the smugly dismissive not-your-average-normie who responds to every mention of buddhism with an overplayed and poorly thought-out accusation of romanticized orientalism.
This is a really bizarre set of assumptions to make based on ‘I’m pretty sure the meme is just saying the average westerner doesn’t know much about Buddhist history’, which is just true if you aren’t a religion nerd or a history nerd. Good luck with all that, though
What part of what I said was an assumption?
It sounds to me like the people making assumptions are the ones trying to depict buddhism as violent merely because they can point to one or two extremist factions, while ignoring the entire rest of the history and context of it and the fact that those extremist factions are aberrations and not the norm.
We all know of edgelords who think "anti-religion" is a virtue to signal, but let's be honest with ourselves and admit that it's just another form of bigotry, ignorance, and hate.
If you don’t want to engage in good faith I can’t make you, have a day 👍
You're the one engaging in bad faith. The whole basis of the rhetoric from this post is an attempt to brew hatred and intolerance based on ignorance.
I'm critiquing that, and instead of engaging with that critique, you're attempting to rationalize the rhetoric and dismiss the critique with handwaving about how some ostensible genius found an example or two in history of some righteous jerks misusing surface-level appearances of buddhism to commit atrocities.
But by confusing those surface-level appearances for actual buddhism, you're revealing your own ignorance. That's like confusing zionism for Judaism. It's the same exact cognitive distortion.
I mean, I'm going to continue studying and practicing buddhism because it's been of benefit to me in my life, and also because I believe it has a lot to offer the world. If you won't even try to engage with its actual content because you'd rather stoke ignorance-based fear and hatred from an anti-religious moral pedestal, that's fine. I don't proselytize.
I just feel sorry for you in that case, and I feel sorry for everyone who won't receive the benefit of buddhist teachings because of the rhetoric used by people like you.
The point of the post is a reaction to people who say "Stop saying all religions are bad and lead people to violence. I'm Buddhist and we never did anything wrong!"
OP's post is a reaction to people who react to people who say "all religions are bad" by saying "nuh uh, Buddhists never did anything wrong". Your experience or lack thereof with such people will dictate whether this feels like a strawman or not.
It is most definitely not a "Buddhism is bad because some Buddhists are bad" argument.
In that case, the problem originates in playing the game thats rules are set by the ignorant in the first place.
If someone says "all religions are bad," the proper response isn't to engage with it as you would with a rational argument made in good faith; i.e. by perhaps offering counterexamples. Because it's not a rational argument made in good faith.
The proper response is to reject the assertion on the basis that its an absolute statement and an overgeneralization. And then going into the ethics of such a chauvinistic, exceptionalistic, and culturally-imperialistic statement as "all religions are bad."
The point isn't to put any religion on a pedestal. But anti-religious bigotry doesn't belong on that pedestal either.
Okay you're gonna have to explain to me what the heck anti-theism has to do with chauvinism or imperialism or bigotry or any of those words. Cause it sounds like you're doing an academia word salad to sound superior to others, but whose text when you parse it doesn't really mean anything at all. Like Jordan Peterson, but leftish.
seems to be one of those people who wants to say, "ah but my particular interpretation of my particular religion is good, it's just all the other ones that are bad"
You couldn't be further from the truth. I'm literally arguing against the categorical dismissal of religions as a whole based on ignorant overgeneralizations.
How do you arrive at the conclusion that I'm arguing for some particular supremacy of one religion?
In fact, the only supremacist standpoint in this argument is the anti-religion one, because it attempts to assert itself upon unwilling subjects.
Note that I never said you can't be atheist. I don't care what you do or don't believe and/or practice in terms of religion or lackthereof. All I said was that you can't tell other people what they can or can't believe/practice as well.
What part of that is so hard to understand?
How does that not make sense to you? Did I not already adequately explain this?
Religion is ingrained in many cultures to the point where you can't separate the two. If you go around trying to ban religion, you're therefore doing cultural imperialism by attempting to assert your own worldview (in this case, atheism) on others. Like bolshevik pogroms. Those were anti-religion too. Does that make them okay?
That's where bigotry and chauvinism come into this.
And don't compare me to Jordan Peterson, I'm nothing like him.
Also when did I ever say anything about being superior to anyone? My entire stance here is that people with anti-religious stances can't feel superior either, as that would be a form of exceptionalism.
When I say "stop feeling superior to others," do you perceive that as a claim that I'm somehow superior to you? If so, you might want to get checked for NPD, because you don't seem able to handle criticism.
And if this sounds like word salad to you then you need to expand your vocabulary.
Lol. Looks like I found someone who genuinely doesn't see how any religion is dangerous bullshit source of endless suffering. Tell me, please, how does it feel to not know that?
On the contrary, you don't see how dangerous it is to express outright contempt for all religions and religion as a whole? And you don't see how you're the one being chauvinistic here?
But go on, continue with your absolutizing statements. That's usually a sign of dunning-kruger, but I'm sure this time is probably an exception. After all, how could someone so smug possibly be wrong?
Lol. So that's how it feels. Have a nice kruger effect then
I guess the flaw is already in the wording: (from the post) "Buddhism never did anything problematic", Buddhism cannot do anything, people can (in the name of Buddhism)
Yeah, it seems any doctrine can be malappropriated by people who never tried to understand it and twisted toward some diabolical purpose. That doesn't mean the doctrine at its core is flawed.
I'm against religious extremism as much as anyone else. But I'm also against generalizing entire cultures based on the actions of extremist factions. There's no way to convince me that could be based in anything other than ignorance.
"
Good for you, you can hold that opinion as long as you don't try to take away anyone's right to following their own beliefs/religions/paths (inasmuch as they themselves are not using it to harm or oppress others, of course; but in those cases you can prosecute the extremism without persecuting the belief systems).
In case you don't already understand this, in many places, religion is so deeply and inextricably intertwined with culture that it would be impossible for you to outlaw religion without committing cultural imperialism.
So in that since "anti-religion" can be just as dogmatic, chauvinistic, ignorant, and oppressive as religion can be.
When I said I oppose religious extremism, that includes anti-religious extremism. You don't get a pass just because you claim your worldview is better. Everyone believes their own worldview to be the best. That isn't justification to repress other worldviews.
In other words, if ignorance is a sin, you're just as sinful as the rest of us. Find me the person with infinite and perfect knowledge of all that is, and I will show you someone who is sinless.
This may sound absurdly simplistic but think about it. Suppose (to take the most improbable example) you decided, or were told and chose to believe the world was created by an invisible entity who, despite all the evidence that he or she occasionally disliked us but was mostly indifferent actually loved us and thought about us all the time . Suppose, piling absurdity upon improbability, you also decided, or were told to believe , that this same person decided to split himself in two and turn one part of himself into an ordinary person like you and me and pay a visit to a desert tribe and get himself arrested and executed for treason, at which point he performed a conjuring trick, came back to from the dead, vanished mysteriously but planned to return and punish all the bad people and make everything nice (though in the meantime, the bad people could go on getting away with it and the good people go on getting buggered up by the bad people-that is, when they were not getting cancer, or run over or bankrupt. Or tortured, of flogged or were worked like beasts or raped or killed in power struggles which were nothing to do with them) Suppose you were misguided enough to believe that lot. What you would do? Would you devote all your spare hours to finding someone who would disabuse of these intently peculiar delusions, so that you could finally sleep at night? Or would you go, once a week or more, to listen to someone telling you that you were quite and every thing you believed was true and what’s more, if you ever stopped believing it, terrible things would happen to you even after you had died?
Okay, first of all, what does anything you just said have to do with buddhism?
I'm familiar with evangelical christian religious trauma. I spent a large chunk of my twenties recovering from that, and I've become pretty good at spotting it in real time. You don't have to convince me of its toxicity.
But that leads me into my second point: as long as those people aren't hurting/abusing/oppressing/exploiting others, I don't give a shit if they trade the one life they're given for a mediocre existence because they're scared of what the preacher says will happen to them otherwise. I mean I can feel compassion for them, but I can't help them unless they want to be helped. And the moment someone like that indicates that they're ready to leave the cave of ignorance, I'll take them by the hand and lead them out, as far as I can at least, because ultimately that's a path they'll have to walk themselves.
I don't go so far as to believe I need to destroy religion. Because as I've already said, that's as chauvinistic and intolerant as it is exceptionalist. And it will only perpetuate cycles of animosity, fear, and hatred; which does not cultivate understanding or bridge gaps or reduce ignorance. Quite the opposite.
Now, if someone is hurting/abusing/oppressing/exploiting others, then they should be held accountable for those harms. That's whether they do it in the name or religion or anything else, including if they do it in the name of anti-religion.
And I'm prepared to die on this hill, so...
What is your solution to the paradox of tolerance? If you believe in a permissive tolerant society, as you appear to, then do you not see a danger where by tolerating the intolerant, we allow them to grow and become stronger, to the point where they could drag us back to the more intolerant and judgemental times of our societies' recent past?
First of all, can you define tolerance & intolerance as articulated in the actual paradox posed by the source instead of distortion regurgitated on social media? It was a footnote in the political philosophy book The Open Society and Its Enemies comparing political systems (the philosophies underpinning them) by defending the merits of open society (such as liberal democracy) over its newer, more fashionable competitors at the time (totalitarianism such as fascism & communism). The colloquial notion of intolerance used in social media (bigotry, exclusionary ideas disrespectful of differences) isn't the meaning in political philosophy. There, the scope of discussion is political systems governing society. Accordingly, tolerance means the acceptance of objectionable beliefs or practices, and intolerance means their rejection.
The original passage is illuminating
The type of intolerance they refer to is the kind that uses force and refuses debate, thus violating open society. They even explicitly reject that we should in general "suppress the utterance of intolerant philosophies" as long as rational argument & public opinion still govern public choice.
In general, the paradox is resolved by drawing a distinction between intolerance of a tolerant society and other kinds of intolerance: intolerance of a tolerant society is an objectionable element, and intolerance of that objectionable element is a distinct element. A tolerant society can coherently reject the objectionable element and accept intolerance of the objectionable element.
An open society is governed through public choice driven nonviolently by conditions of open inquiry, intellectual freedom, and competitive deliberation. In that context, open society is the tolerant society, and it may reject intolerance of the open society. Intolerance of an open society is literally rejecting it by violating it, ie, unjustified force or violence. Beliefs alone do not end nonviolent public choice.
Consequently, no matter how objectionable their ideas, someone who permits nonviolent public choice and conditions for it still accepts open society: they are not intolerant of open society. They are not the subject of the paradox. To the contrary, those who would suppress their liberties are enemies of open society.
Social media totally butchered the entire thesis!
The intolerant of the paradox must literally not tolerate open society by violating it. They aren't merely "intolerant" in the looser, colloquial sense.
Open society is in no danger of the "intolerant" dragging them anywhere as long as the rest of society exercises their liberties to maintain the institutions of open society and beat them at public choices. If they can't manage even that despite all the capacity granted to the public to do it, then society itself has pretty much forfeited open society.
I never said we should tolerate the intolerant.
I said we shouldn't make generalizations about entire cultural traditions based on a few cherrypicked examples of extremists using them as a veneer of legitimacy.
Because trying to ban religions as a whole, would be an intolerant position.
I've already explicitly said in this thread that if someone is harming or oppressing people, whether in the name of religion or anti-religion or anything else, then they should be held accountable for the harm and oppression that they committed. Not for the halfbaked views that they misused to try to justify their actions.
How is that tolerating intolerance? It seems fairly balanced and rational.
Let's have a calm and measured discussion. This is a challenge I'm setting myself as much as you.
I don't know where you come from, but in most places in the world, you don't have to go far back in time before you get to a point where exploiting the weak and oppressing the marginalised were cornerstones of society.
Horrible as it may be, the natural order of things is unjust, cruel and callous. It has always been this way, it's not a modern deviation from an idyllic past where we lived in harmony with nature. The number one rule of nature has always been that the strong have dominion over the weak.
I'm saying this because if we want to make a better more just world, we should first acknowledge the scale of the task. We are trying to outwit nature herself. We are trying to build a fair society out of nothing but the cold uncaring laws of physics.
To do this, we have to dismantle the traditional hierarchies of society in order to replace them with something better, something transparent and equitable. Sorry brother but this means religion has got to go. Religion is pure distilled tradition. There's just no place for unquestioning obedience and mindless submission in a just and fair society.
And if we want a just and fair society, there can no place for magical thinking. Magical thinking is the other thing you let in the door along with religion. But no one has a pure source of perfect knowledge inside their head just by wishing for it. Knowledge requires work, it can always be challenged and overturned.
Yeah, that's a shame, and we should work to overcome that.
It's a good thing buddhism doesn't encourage that.
It's a good thing buddhism doesn't have that.
It's a good thing buddhism doesn't claim that.
Yes, and buddhism encourages its practitioners to do precisely this.
This is what I mean when I say people in this threads are making judgements and generalizations from ignorance. In other words, without knowledge.
Because they apparently don't know much about buddhism, other than a few cherrypicked examples of factions who misused it. And they're also projecting western notions of religion onto buddhism where those notions don't fit. You could call it a philosophy, a culture, a way of life, a practice, and that would all be just as accurate.
My relationship to buddhism isn't particularly religious, but for some people it is. But even for those people, when we call them religious, it's in a very different sense than people mean when they say an american evangelical christian is religious.
People who can't see the distinction have no grounds on which to make sweeping condemnations of religion as a whole.
And you're not going to get ~~millions~~ billions of people to abandon their religions, buddhism or otherwise. To attempt to do so, to insist on it, is to be chauvinistic.
And if you think buddhist traditions are about enforcing hierarchies where the strong have dominion over the weak, then you simply don't understand buddhism. And trying to eliminate it by dismantling the tradition of teacher-student transmission lineages is an attempt on your part to exercise dominion over others. That doesn't create a just or a fair world. It only enforces your own view of propriety on people who never asked for it.
How about this for something better, something transparent and equitable: let people live their lives how they see fit as long as they're letting you live your life as you see fit. That's all it takes.
If everyone can agree to that, we don't have to make up problems about other people and ways of life that "need to go." Anti-religion doesn't get an exception. And as long as people are trying to write themselves exceptions to that, everyone else is going to write themselves the same exception and the cycles of animosity will perpetuate.
The goal should be to break those cycles of animosity, which can only be done by accepting differences. Trying to crush worldviews and ways of life that differ from the ones you hold, doesn't break that cycle. It only keeps it spinning.
The only way to exit that cycle is to accept that other people have differences, and that that's okay and it's how things have always been and will always be.
I'll point out that not once did I even suggest that we should tolerate intolerance. Because intolerance and oppression are not "live and let live." Those are precisely the things I'm here arguing against. But trying to force the world to abandon religious diversity, is a form of intolerance and oppression. Plain and simple.
Hey if you're finding this thread stressful, you should just leave it, take a break, clear your head. Then, only if you feel like it, come back to it. It's easy to get sucked into online debates like this, and sometimes it's not constructive or beneficial for our own wellbeing.
So, assuming you're feeling rested and at ease, I'll respond to your points...
Well I disagree and I think we will do that. In fact, I assume that it will happen, as long as society doesn't suffer a catastrophic setback.
I agree and I am no fan of force, especially when it comes to something as vague and subjective as the meaning of life.
All that's needed is for people to discuss calmly and objectively. In time, we can all reach a consensus.
No one knows anything for sure. We don't know if there's a god, we don't know if our lives have purpose beyond our own satisfaction. We don't know what happens when we die, or before we were born for that matter.
And there's the rub - religion claims to have the answers to these questions. This fundamental deceit at the core of all religion is what makes it toxic, and why it has to go.
Yeah, I shouldn't get so worked up about it, but I view it as dangerous rhetoric so it wouldn't feel right to stand aside and let it fester.
I don't think this is the type of thing where we need a consensus. People can live their own lives as long as they're not harming others. There doesn't need to be consensus on the best cuisines or the best language for poetry. These are cultural phenomena, and as such, diversity is a good thing.
Buddhism doesn't claim to know the answers to any of those things. It'll just take the student by the hand and encourage them to inquire and gain insight into the nature of reality.
It doesn't give answers to anything, except occasionally as pedagogical tools which are later discarded once their lessons are learned.
This is what I mean by saying westerners tend to project western notions of religion into eastern religions where those western notions don't fit. "This fundamental deceit at the core of all religion is what makes it toxic" is a valuation statement you're making based on the western religions you're more familiar with.
Do shitty people who pretend to teach buddhism exist? Yes, and they're a recognized problem among credible buddhist teachers. You really shouldn't discredit the credible ones based on the actions of the scammers and cultists.
I know what you mean, I feel the same when I see someone making excuses for religion!
So I think we do actually. You see, in this modern world where we are all connected and empowered, I think it's increasingly important for individuals to be able to think critically and objectively, and to be able to identify and discard magical thinking.
It doesn't matter if some particular person's magical thinking produces outcomes which are nice or harmless according to your or my judgement. Magical thinking is inherently unstable, and it can lead people to commit atrocities.
You're right that I don't know much about buddhism. I do want to say that I'm uneasy about the "east" vs "west" division you're making though, I don't think it's accurate and it feels divisive. I'm most familiar with what I call the Jewish religions i.e. Judaism and its offshoots: the Jesus cults, and the Mohammed cults. None of these are really from the west, Judaism obviously originated in the area we now call Palestine, which is also where the Christ figure lived and died. Mohammed lived and died to the west of that, in Arabia, but still, not really in "the West". I know I know, the Romans spread Christianity through Europe, but that's only one subgroup of that Jewish family of religions.
My point is that I don't find east vs west a helpful distinction. Something more precise might be Vedic religions vs all the others. I don't know if that's an actual term, but Buddhism is one of the many religions which hold the Vedic texts sacred, isn't it? Like Hinduism, which was never really the single monolithic religion it's presented as outside of India.
So to get back on track, what I have heard about Buddhism is interesting. I worked with a guy who called himself a Buddhist, I remember him saying that Buddhists don't believe in a creator god, nor that karma is a system designed to punish or reward people, rather it's simply a "mechanism" whereby the path you take through reincarnation is guided by the state of your soul - these are my words not his, he said something to that effect, I don't remember exactly what he said now, he didn't use the word soul.
Anyway I found it an interesting viewpoint. I've thought myself that if you believe our conscious experience is a physical phenomenon that is caused entirely by our brains, then reincarnation would seem to be inevitable, because something similar enough to my brain is bound to exist again at some other time outside of my current life. Put another way, if you have infinite time, then anything which is possible will happen an infinite number of times.
Another thing which pops into my head about Buddhism is a story I remember reading some time ago (probably over 10 years ago) where the Dalai Lama said that if science were to disprove reincarnation or something else about his beliefs, then he would have to accept that and change his view. I thought that was a good position for a leader of a religion to hold, although someone later said that he only said that because he knew science would never be able to prove or disprove such a thing.
So if you're telling me that Buddhism doesn't have any books of revealed truths which dictate how you should live or which pass judgement on others for not living (or loving) in the ordained way, and doesn't have some hierarchy of people who have some magical communication channel with supernatural entities that normal people don't have, and also doesn't depend on magical thinking at all, then maybe it is different. I'm certainly open to that possibility.
I've never attempted to excuse the actions of particular religious people or sects who cause harm. And I don't need to make excuses for ones who don't.
Is that what people in this thread are doing? Because it seems like you're the only one even attempting to engage with this rationally. Everyone else just discards or ignores every point that I make, and then they default to some cookie-cutter arguments for why they need to enforce their worldview on others and how it's actually okay when they do it because they gave themselves a special exception to the exact thing they're criticizing other people for, which is the feelings of supremacy thay many (not all) religious people hold.
Which is, again, not something that I excused, so focusing on that instead of the content of what I'm saying is a strawman.
Nothing I've argued in this entire thread has been "magical thinking."
It's not magical thinking. The benefits of buddhism are backed by science. You're making so many assumptions, and even when I point them out you keep making them.
Buddhism originated in the eastern part of the globe. Even in modern scholarship "East" and "West" are clean shorthands commonly used to categorize different philosophies and religions. In an academic context, the meaning will be understood.
Yeah, Abrahamic religions originated in the Middle East (or more accurately West Asia), yet they're mostly included in the history of western civilizations and thus categorized as "West"
"Eastern" schools of thought can refer to ideas from Arabia and Persia (and sometimes even Byzantium), but typically it refers distinctively to South Asian and East Asian schools of thought.
That's not really divisive, it's just descriptive. If someone tries to claim Buddhism originated in the West, they'd be wrong. Unless you're speaking from East Asia and referring to the Indian subcontinent as "the West," which happens in a famous koan about Bodhidharma.
But that doesn't change how those terms are used in scholarship, because it's a useful distinction.
Buddhism has Vedic origins in the same way Christianity has Judaic origins, but calling Buddhism a "Vedic religion" would be just as incorrect or more as calling Christianity a "Jewish religion."
Buddhism does not hold the Vedic texts as sacred, and for the most part doesn't even use them. A buddhist scholar might read them for historical or dialectical reasons, but they don't really have a place in buddhist practice or canon.
There are many ideas buddhism inherits from the Vedic tradition, but many of them are redefined or reinterpreted in the Buddhist canon, and some are rejected entirely. The most famous distinction is in how the Vedas propose an essential selfhood, whereas Buddhism says there is no essential selfhood.
Which is an idea that influenced post-modernism, a mostly-western (as that distinction does begin to break down by the 20th century) school of thought at the root of the atheist movement that people in this thread are such staunch proponents of.
That is correct. Buddhism on the other hand is technically one religion, as it traces back to the same founder. However it's also a very diverse tradition with different schools of thought and practice lineages that emerged in different regions and at different times.
Unlike western religions, Buddhism often cross-pollinated/integrated with the existing cultures, and so many regional variants today preserve elements of the indigenous/animist folk traditions of the areas they sprung up. Because it wasn't about conquest or forced conversions like we see in the history of western religions. The closest comparison we have in the west is a few symbols from pagan holidays, like "christmas" trees and easter eggs.
Your coworker was mostly correct about buddhism not having deities (except for in specific cases where they assimilated the local pantheon, but even in those cases they're viewed as useful symbols rather than mysterious space ghosts with actual existence).
He was also correct about karma being viewed as a mechanism rather than a contrived system of punishments. Like how if you punch a wall, the wall punches back with equal and opposite force. But on a cosmic scale.
That part is a misconception though, it sounds like you're referring to Maya which is a Hindu concept. That's the thing that says "the world is illusion." Buddhism doesn't claim that, and in fact it asserts that the world of sensory phenomena is real and should be treated as such.
Also, not all buddhists believe in reincarnation, especially in modern times. Most buddhists believe in science, and even the ones who believe in an afterlife often do so in a sort of agnostic skepticism, like "maybe, maybe not, won't know till we get there. Better to live here and now while we can."
Buddhist texts are not "revealed texts" in the way many religions claim their texts to be. There are some regional variants that have similar concepts, but it's not a part of the overall buddhist canon and most buddhist schools of thought don't rely on that sort of thing. In fact one of the main points of Zen Buddhism is that you should reject external authorities and fixed ideas.
[Edit to add: also, buddhism isn't about passing judgement. It's more about radical acceptance. That doesn't mean tolerating harms, but accepting reality as it is. And that includes the fact that other people live their lives in their own ways, and that won't always align with one's own ways, and that's okay.
There is also the Vinaya, which is a monastic code, and only applies to monks. It's a set of rules intended to foster a healthy/harmonious community and prevent abuses or other friction that can occur when hundreds of people live together.
Thirdly, there are the precepts, which practitioners are encouraged to follow. But these are more "guidelines for virtuous living" intended to maintain inner and outer harmony, rather than "rules/commandments for moral conduct" like we see in western religions. Most of the precepts boil down to "Do no harm, not even to yourself." And doing wrong, such as hurting someone, is also viewed as harming oneself.]
There is lineage in buddhism, and that described the teacher→student relationships as they're passed down from generation to generation. But it's not about supernatural communications. It's how they certify/recognize the authenticity of various teachers, and also distinguishes between different schools of thought and practices that can have a range of subtle distinctions (like Rinzai Zen or Soto Zen, for instance).
The only magical thinking you'll find is in preserved elements from regional indigenous traditions that existed before buddhism, and the reason those are preserved is because buddhism explicitly did not come to conquer and enforce one worldview over another. It only brought enlightenment, which is for everybody.
And it's not mystical, it's just being fully present here and now, perceiving accurately, empty of preconceived notions, and not driven by the incessant urges to seek pleasure and run from pain (nor to seek pain and run from pleasure, either).
the person you're talking to right now is on a full on crusade in this thread posting the same shit over and over, i'm guessing because they are personally offended by this post. you're better off not engaging.
haha ok thanks for the heads up!
It's not a crusade, and I wouldn't have to say the same things over and over if people didn't keep ignoring literally everything I say to put words in my mouth and make the same points they already made which I then have to debunk again the same way that I already did.
Personally offended? People in this thread are literally talking about destroying entire cultures simply because they don't believe in those people's religion. I will always take issue with that. Is that a personal offense?
Who exactly? Wasn't there a military coup? What is the connection to Buddhism?
Yeah, it's a military coup, and they're killing Buddhists too. But of course they found some fake buddhists to side with the junta to try to try and lend it some semblance of legitimacy.
So people are latching onto that and trying to say it's Buddhism's fault, because I guess that sounds edgy?