As our evolution slows and industrialization and technology accelerates, a growing body of research suggests that human biology is struggling to keep pace. Many of the chronic stress-related health issues we face today aren’t personal failings or modern inconveniences – they’re the predictable result of forcing Stone Age physiology into a world it was never built for.
A fascinating new study from University of Zurich researchers has investigated whether the rapid and extensive environmental shifts of the current Anthropocene have compromised the fitness of Homo sapiens. In less-evolutionary speak: if the world most of us experience daily is having a profound impact on mental and physical health as a species.
Synthesizing data concerning industrialization and urbanization and health, the researchers argue that there are many signs that humans haven't had time to adapt to the rapid changes in the world over the last century. They cite declining global fertility rates, rising chronic inflammatory conditions and other chronic health trends as signs that we've been struggling on Earth since the Industrial Revolution.
We live in a society, and it's killing us.
Out of curiosity I checked if their sources properly accounted for confounding variables (e.g. age, because the global population is aging). I didn't check all, but all the sources that did I check accounted for age properly.
Then I scanned some more. To bring a medical viewpoint into the discussion, took a particularly close look at one of the referenced studies of 67 health risk factors, to determine if it's stress, pollutants, communicable or environment-triggred disease that is harming people most.
The factors dishing out most harm seem to be diseases with a lifestyle / stress component (high blood pressure), behaviour patterns with a stress component (overconsumption of food and intoxicants, primarily alcocol and tobacco), and only after these comes home air pollution (cooking with open fire in developing countries). Outdoor air pollution ("ambient particulate matter pollution") isn't in the top 5, but one one diagram, it's factor number six.
(Reservation of judgement: there's not enough data yet about chemicals in the food chain. Pesticides and microplastics definitely need attention, there is absolutely no reason to expect no effect. The effect has to be measured and summarized.)
Quoting the relevant passage from "A comparative risk assessment of burden of disease and injury attributable to 67 risk factors and risk factor clusters in 21 regions, 1990-2010: a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2010"
My personal conclusion: it's not pollutants harming us yet. Pollutant densities may well increase (but many are decreasing, e.g. people are cooking less with gas and solid fuel) but our social conditions are stressful as shit, and that encourages certain behaviours which have an evolutionary factor.
E.g. people are prone to over-eat when they have plentiful food, even if the food is junk and there's no need to eat more. A sedentary lifestyle and driving instead of walking then doubles down on that. People are prone to relieve stress by consuming tobacco and alcohol, despite it harming them. Our ancestors didn't have an unlimited access to food, booze and stuff to smoke for a passtime, and didn't evolve defense mechanisms against such behaviour patterns.
But as usual, culture getst to be the first responder. Genes will take millenia to get anything done, but culture can get things done in decades. Awareness of how people harm their health, and awareness of how society may be encouraging self-harm, needs to spread.
Thanks for your analysis - really valuable comment.
My hunch has always been that social stressors play the biggest part in this. I have no idea if/when we'll see something that reverses what's gone wrong. I'm sure there are local pockets of success but with society/communication/economics becoming more global and homogeneous I think it might take something pretty enormous.
At the end of the day, at least in out lifetimes, I just think it's incredibly sad that humanity has come so far, at so much cost, just to experience so much collective and personal desperation.