This is the biggest brain-dead take out of all of them. Go ahead, please do find any study that shows trans women commit assaults at anywhere near the rates of cis men. Because if this is the argument you're trying to make, you had better actually have some evidence for it.

Feels like a what? Define "woman" without using the word woman.

You keep saying this like it's some gotcha, but clearly you haven't read my comments. I already told you (twice) definitions do stem originally from biological sex, I've already conceded this from the very beginning, but that I still don't think this matters or is a terribly convincing reason to say "nope you're not a woman because historically our ideas of what a woman is stem entirely from DNA and your sex organs". Agree to disagree on this I guess. Again it's weird how you want to make sure people have vaginas.

This triggers you massively, it seems.

I have daughters. I have a wife. I don't want them losing opportunities that are meant for women to males. I don't want them sharing changing rooms or bathrooms, made for women, with males. They don't want to because it makes them uncomfortable in a place where they should be safe and comfortable. Essentially all sexual assaults are committed by males on females. If there are no males in a female place, the females are safer than if there are.

As above, you're just asserting something about safety, but I also wanted to add that 1. Changing rooms and bathrooms really should be separate stalls. It's really weird (to me) that you're expected to change in a room with other people in it. 2. What opportunities? Vaguely sport is the only one that could make sense to me - but we can create new categories there not based on gender too (there are weight classes in certain sports, wouldn't be crazy to do something similar there too bases on biology, and not gender)...

Basically. Get a grip mate. This is such a tiny issue.

Identify politics is such a waste of time.

I'd much rather be talking about fighting the ruling class, they're actually impacting our lives...

[–] FreedomAdvocate@lemmy.net.au 0 points 1 week ago

This is the biggest brain-dead take out of all of them. Go ahead, please do find any study that shows trans women commit assaults at anywhere near the rates of cis men. Because if this is the argument you’re trying to make, you had better actually have some evidence for it.

Way to miss the point. Trans women are males, therefor are significantly more likely to sexually assault a woman than a female is. Letting trans women have unfettered access to womens safe spaces is like letting a wolf into the hen house.

I already told you (twice) definitions do stem originally from biological sex, I’ve already conceded this from the very beginning, but that I still don’t think this matters or is a terribly convincing reason to say “nope you’re not a woman because historically our ideas of what a woman is stem entirely from DNA and your sex organs”.

You still can't define what a woman is though. I'm asking you to give me your definition of "woman" without using the word woman. If you can't it means that woman can't be defined, and that means it essentially doesn't exist. It erases women. It's deeply misogynistic.

This triggers you massively, it seems.

lol good one. Right back at you buddy.

Changing rooms and bathrooms really should be separate stalls.

They are? Women don't all just stand around peeing on the floor lol. Being separate stalls doesn't change the fact that if you let men in to the women's safe space, women are no longer safe. Women have to go in and out of the stalls still.

What opportunities? Vaguely sport is the only one that could make sense to me - but we can create new categories there not based on gender too (there are weight classes in certain sports, wouldn’t be crazy to do something similar there too bases on biology, and not gender)…

Women's sport was not created because of gender, it was created because of sex. Males and females are biologically different, and women would win literally nothing if they had to compete against men - hence, Women's sport. Go find a women's sport world record that is even comparable to the corresponding men's one. Good luck.

It's not just sports either, it's everything from scholarships to jobs to awards, and many more. Basically everything that was separated by Sex. They were done so because men and women are fundamentally different.

Basically. Get a grip mate. This is such a tiny issue.

It's not a tiny issue for women though. If it's such a tiny issue, why can't trans women just use the men's spaces? Trans women are in less danger in a men's room than women are with a trans woman in a women's room, factually and statistically.

I’d much rather be talking about fighting the ruling class, they’re actually impacting our lives…

It's possible to talk about more than 1 issue at a time.